
Are you caught in the insider trap?
Are you caught in the insider trap? Learn to identify signs of leadership stagnation and explore effective ways to reset your approach for sustained success....

by Jennifer Jordan Published April 30, 2026 in Brain Circuits • 3 min read
When becoming leader of a group of which you were a peer member, it’s natural to assume you can maintain the same relationships you had before and people will treat you the same, but they do not. You will be excluded more than you think – and it feels lonelier than you might expect.
As you are now making decisions over them, people will try to interpret everything you do, which makes you much more self-conscious about your appearance and behavior. This can be quite anxiety-inducing, for you and your team.
Now that you’re boss, you might think you had greater control of your agenda, but the opposite is true. PR issue blowing up? Time to abandon your holiday and catch the next flight home.
People talk more about you, but much less to you, so you don’t get feedback in the same way, which can really play with your mind as it becomes its own echo-chamber.
… but once you’ve made the decision, you have to own it. And, unless it goes well, people will distance themselves from that decision, and you, regardless of what they said before.
You have to recognize your team when things go well, but take the hit when they don’t. That’s just good leadership, but it can still be tough to share the successes yet swallow the failures.
The first step to dealing with becoming a leader is to accept that these things are going to happen and that you need to prepare for them. They may still take a toll, but at least they won’t catch you unawares.
Ensure you have people at your level to whom you can talk, inside or outside the company, because they will understand your situation. You need someone you can rely on not simply for emotional support, but also for feedback – but don’ t rely on people in your team or below you to fill the gap.
Share small insights into how you are looking or feeling with people. This is about trying to forestall their conjectures about you, so they don’t invent their own explanations for your appearance or behavior.
Work is life and life is work now, so finding a balance is hard. Block out non-negotiable “me” time, even if it’s just 15 minutes in the morning. Use the time to breathe and reflect on the day ahead.
Before a decision is made, allow everyone to have their say and let them know their voices are heard. Then, once the decision is made, try to shut their voices out, or you’ll go crazy with endless revisiting. Instead, look at the decision purely from your perspective. What went well? What not so well? What could we have done differently? Then move on.
Becoming a leader can feel lonely. Lower your expectations, accept the new dynamics, and make sure you have a ready support network for help and advice.

Professor of Leadership and Organizational Behavior
Jennifer Jordan is a social psychologist and Professor of Leadership and Organizational Behavior at IMD. Jennifer’s teaching, research, and consulting focus on the areas of digital leadership, ethics, influence, and power. She has received specialized training and certifications in lie and truthfulness detection, as well as in conflict resolution within organizations. She is Program Director of the Women on Boards and the Leadership Essentials program, and co-Director of the Leading Digital Execution program.

10 hours ago • by Jing Yan in Brain Circuits
Are you caught in the insider trap? Learn to identify signs of leadership stagnation and explore effective ways to reset your approach for sustained success....

May 19, 2026 • by Estie Alessandrini in Brain Circuits
Use neuroscience and small, measurable actions to build a resilient leadership brain – adaptive, balanced, and primed for peak performance....

May 14, 2026 • by Robyn Wilson in Brain Circuits
Strengthen your multicultural leadership approach by reflecting on biases, encouraging inclusion, and fostering trust within diverse teams....

May 13, 2026 • by April Rinne in Brain Circuits
AI is reshaping industries overnight, and remote work is redefining professional relationships. Adopt a Flux Mindset™ to help navigate overwhelming change....
Explore first person business intelligence from top minds curated for a global executive audience