Facebook Facebook icon Twitter Twitter icon LinkedIn LinkedIn icon Email


No, AI has not killed supply chain management

Published 4 May 2021 in Technology ‚ÄĘ 4 min read

Some have argued that supply chain management is on its way to becoming obsolete.  Recent events would seem suggest otherwise.  


Death of Supply Chain? 

Almost three years ago, Harvard Business Review published a provocative article entitled¬†‚ÄėThe Death of Supply Chain Management‚Äô.¬† It became as viral as an article on Supply Chain Management can be, circulating¬†widely¬†on Twitter and LinkedIn.¬† The authors posited that the advent of Industry 4.0 technologies, the digitalization of data, and the growth of advanced analytics, machine learning and AI would mean that¬†‚Äúwithin 5-10 years, the supply chain function may be obsolete, replaced by a smoothly running, self-regulating utility that¬†‚Ķ¬†requires very little human intervention.‚Ä̬†

That’s not how things have turned out so far.  It seems that more than ever, the supply chain manager is a critical contributor to the performance of their company. 


The Pandemic That Changed Everything 

The obvious place to start considering why is the pandemic that has upended supply chains around the world for the past year.  With lockdowns changing consumer behavior, some of the weaknesses of hyper-optimized supply chains have been exposed.  From toilet paper manufacturing that could not easily switch between industrial and residential formats to eggs and flour prepared and packaged in separate streams for consumers and commercial needs, many supply chains struggled to adapt. 

The ones that did, however, were because managers collaborated across business silos¬†to remove complexity and focus on key SKUs¬†at the intersection of manufacturing speed and high sales volume.¬† Rather than being obsolete, one senior marketing executive at a major FMCG company told us¬†‚ÄúI knew my supply chain was a key strategic advantage, but I had not realized how much it could be a key tactical advantage as well.‚Ä̬†

Another impact of the pandemic was an explosion in e-commerce, leaving companies scrambling to adapt their order treatment and fulfilment activities to meet the demand.  With stores closed in many markets, this became a matter of survival, with supply chain front and center.  Many companies are now trying to push their omni-channel strategies as a way to build in free supply chain resilience for the future.   

Of course, the pandemic was very much unchartered waters for all of us.  But the next time might be an earthquake in Japan, an economic downturn due to a financial crisis, a volcano in Iceland, new trade tariff wars, or even a major global waterway closure.  The recent days-long blockage of the Suez Canal may spur some companies to rethink their global supply chain footprints, both internal and external.  This will require careful consideration of the quantifiable cost of freight and customs duties, but also the more nuanced impacts of reactivity, agility and working capital that require a supply chain manager’s participation. 


The Supply Chain Spotlight 

Even without pandemics and headline-grabbing logistics snafus, supply chains are front-of-mind more than ever.  The waves of exciting capabilities brought by Industry 4.0 technologies have impacts beyond the world of supply chain management.  Companies leading the way in digital transformation have understood that these technologies are opportunities to rethink their value proposition, for example through personalization, and not merely a way to automate away their supply chains. 

The potential impacts of industrial automation and AI have led to discussions about structural change to the economy, jobs and even to society at large.  The entrance of supply chain management into the mainstream has gotten the attention of those looking for a promising career choice. Gartner, the supply chain advisory and research company, has seen the U.S. university masters programs in supply chain in its ranking grow 170% from 2016 to 2020. 


A Seat at the Table 

As much as we would like supply chains to be simple and predictable enough to run themselves, a more achievable goal would be for supply chain mangers to leverage all of the exciting capabilities available to automate the routine, and to build visibility and agility for the next unforeseeable problem.     

A recent survey by IMD revealed that the highest priority for supply chain managers was to implement Sales and Operations Planning  Рa process that requires deep cross-functional collaboration Рand integrate the supply chain strategy and the business strategy.  Rather than looking to slot supply chain as an autonomous function, companies are looking more than ever to place it squarely in the boardroom.  


Supply Chain Opportunities 

Contributing to this spike is the¬†growing interest¬†of consumers, professionals and investors in¬†sustainability¬†and the circular economy.¬†¬†Many companies look to their supply chains to lead the way in finding solutions to these critical issues.¬†¬†To quote the Head of Strategy from a large multi-national ‚ÄúWe have spoken about¬†end to end¬†supply chain¬†optimization¬†for¬†some¬†years already¬†but the scope,¬†from which end to which¬†end,¬†has changed dramatically for today‚Äôs supply chains.‚Ä̬†¬†

Supply chain executives today,¬†have to¬†navigate ever more complex regulatory (environmental) requirements, give input to IT on how to digitally enable their supply chains and¬†leverage¬†their supply chain a key driver in ongoing business transformations.¬†This way, far from¬†facing death, supply¬†chain managers¬†need to¬†focus on being at the table¬†as an active contributor in shaping¬†the company‚Äôs strategic vision.¬†Or, to¬†invoke¬†common wisdom, it‚Äôs nice to have a strategy¬†‚Ästits¬†far¬†better if you can execute on it and enact¬†it operationally.¬†


Ralf Seifert - IMD Professor

Ralf W. Seifert

Professor of Operations Management at IMD

Ralf W Seifert is Professor of Operations Management at IMD and co-author of The Digital Supply Chain Challenge: Breaking Through. He directs IMD’s Leading the Future Supply Chain (LFSC) program, which addresses both traditional supply chain strategy and implementation issues as well as digitalization trends and the impact of new technologies.

Richard Markoff

Richard Markoff

Supply chain researcher, consultant, coach and lecturer

Richard Markoff is a supply chain researcher, consultant, coach, and lecturer. He has worked in supply chain for L’Oréal for 22 years, in Canada, the US and France, spanning the entire value chain from manufacturing to customer collaboration. He is also Co-founder and Operating Partner of the venture capital firm Innovobot.


Learn Brain Circuits

Join us for daily exercises focusing on issues from team building to developing an actionable sustainability plan to personal development. Go on - they only take five minutes.
Read more 

Explore Leadership

What makes a great leader? Do you need charisma? How do you inspire your team? Our experts offer actionable insights through first-person narratives, behind-the-scenes interviews and The Help Desk.
Read more

Join Membership

Log in here to join in the conversation with the I by IMD community. Your subscription grants you access to the quarterly magazine plus daily articles, videos, podcasts and learning exercises.
Sign up

Log in or register to enjoy the full experience

Explore first person business intelligence from top minds curated for a global executive audience