How to tackle a second-year leadership slump
CEOs can turn early wins into lasting success by recalibrating strategy, aligning teams, and focusing on sustainable growth and performance metrics....
Brain Circuits
Is a lack of trust costing you? How a culture operating system separates winners from losers
Most companies approach culture like they’re trying to boil the ocean: vague values, inspiring speeches, and fingers crossed that something changes. Susanne May highlights the pitfalls of a lack of organizational trust and outlines four key steps to install a culture operating system that will give you a significant competitive advantage.
How a lack of trust hurts performance
When employees distrust leadership, it swiftly produces a trust deficit, with the following adverse outcomes:
- Innovation decline – people withhold new ideas
- Initiative failure – strategic initiatives frequently fail
- Satisfaction drop – customers receive poor service
- Financial decline – discretionary effort vanishes
The four key steps to building a culture operating system
Step 1: Measure what’s happening
Most leadership teams are working on perilous assumptions as hidden cultural dysfunction hurts the bottom line. They assume engagement is high because employees smile in meetings, but they are blind to where decisions get stuck, silos destroy collaboration, and high performers fall silent. The answer lies in robust culture diagnostics that reveal the exact moments where your culture creates or destroys value.
Step 2: Define your decision-making code
Values like “ownership” and “accountability” on a PowerPoint slide provide no behavioral instruction, so culture becomes what the loudest person in the room makes it. Instead of a bunch of inspirational platitudes, you need a core code based on purpose, values, and crisp trade-offs that teaches individuals how to make choices when priorities conflict.
Step 3: Build the human capabilities
Awareness doesn’t drive change: capability does. Your team needs to shift their mindset, change behaviors, and develop hands-on skills to bring your culture code to life daily. That requires the ability to provide feedback that matters, call out the right action in the moment, and hold violations accountable without drama. Strengthen these by focused training and include behavioral feedback loops that turn culture-building into a continuous process, not some activity that was done at an offsite last year.
Step 4: Embed culture into your business system
The inherent failure of most cultural initiatives is that they require a hero to survive. When the hero departs or becomes bored, the initiative dies, and cynicism flourishes. The solution is to embed culture into the systems that already run your company, e.g., linking cultural behaviors to the same dashboards and KPIs as revenue and EBITDA and incorporating them into hiring, onboarding, performance reviews, and promotion decisions.
Key learning
Culture doesn’t shift because you say it should. It shifts when you engineer it systematically. The same way you would architect any mission-critical business system that determines whether you succeed or fail.
Authors
Related
Struggling to give feedback? Here’s how to start
For leaders, giving performance feedback can feel uncomfortable and awkward. Here are the first three prerequisites. ...
The reverse resolution: What NOT to do in 2026
Another January, another list of new resolutions. Meditate daily. Read more books. Network strategically. But what if the fastest path to professional impact isn’t adding something new – it’s subtracting something old?...
Where you look is where you go: Advice from the Saskatchewan Drivers’ Handbook
2025 could be summed up as “OMG, did that really happen, too?” As the new year begins, it’s tempting to focus on battening down the hatches and mitigating the uncertainties. Instead, says...
Learn Brain Circuits
Join us for daily exercises focusing on issues from team building to developing an actionable sustainability plan to personal development. Go on - they only take five minutes.
Explore Leadership
What makes a great leader? Do you need charisma? How do you inspire your team? Our experts offer actionable insights through first-person narratives, behind-the-scenes interviews and The Help Desk.
Join Membership
Log in here to join in the conversation with the I by IMD community. Your subscription grants you access to the quarterly magazine plus daily articles, videos, podcasts and learning exercises.