So, you’re facing a boycott. But will it hurt you in the long run?

Notable recent consumer boycotts

Tesla CEO Elon Musk’s political stances and his online behavior provoked an intense backlash, with long-time customers threatening to boycott the brand. But recent history suggests a more nuanced relationship between controversy, outrage, and long-term firm outcomes. When the dust settles, Tesla might even benefit from the boycott.

In 2012, for example, Chick-fil-A’s CEO publicly opposed same-sex marriage. The backlash was swift, with calls for a boycott across the US – but the outrage also galvanized a countermovement led by former Fox News anchor Mike Huckabee, then Governor of Arkansas. His creation of “Chick-fil-A Appreciation Day” drew massive consumer support, leading to record-breaking sales. Over the next decade, Chick-fil-A rose from 15th to third in US fast-food sales, surpassing Wendy’s, Burger King, and Taco Bell, despite having far fewer locations.

Nike faced a similar storm in 2018 when it made Colin Kaepernick – the NFL quarterback known for taking the knee during the national anthem – the face of its ad campaign. Consumers burned their Nike gear, and the #BoycottNike trended across social media. The day after the ad was released, Nike’s stock dropped nearly 3% – but rebounded quickly, closing the week higher than where it started. By the end of the quarter, sales were up 10% and online engagement had surged by 61%.

The twist in the Tesla tale

Tesla’s case is a new development in the story, with protests coming not from ideological outsiders but from its customer base. This is potentially more damaging. (Anheuser-Busch, for example, lost its position as the best-selling beer in the US after its top brand, Bud Light, collaborated with trans influencer Dylan Mulvaney.)

But here’s the twist: consumer outrage tends to play out over days or weeks, but buying a car is a much slower decision, often taking months or even years. And by the time such purchasing decisions are made, ideological flashpoints will likely have shifted to different issues.

More significantly, when protestors use “radical repertoire” tactics, they may galvanize support from those on the opposite ideological side. In Tesla’s case, the protests may help it penetrate a demographic it has long struggled with when it comes to conservative buyers. Until recently, the brand was an icon of coastal progressives, but amid the backlash, it may now resonate more with audiences who previously disdained it, and the real impact of #TakedownTesla on the firm’s future won’t be known until the dust settles.