HomeResearch & Knowledgeback to HomeSustainabilityback to Research & KnowledgeFalling from grace: Sulzer and the Dow Jones Sustainability Indexback to Sustainability

Case Study

Falling from grace: Sulzer and the Dow Jones Sustainability Index

By Ulrich Steger and Oliver Salzmann

11 pages

October 2002

Order this case study

Reference: IMD-2-0099

In September 2001, Sulzer AG was dropped from the Dow Jones Sustainability Indexes, which is composed by the Zurich-based SAM Group. SAM justified the removal with a badly managed implant recall at a US subsidiary of Sulzer’s former medical division Sulzer Medica, which Sulzer AG had spun off in July 2001. The case illustrates the challenge of conclusively rating companies’ sustainability performance in complex strategic and/or operational situations, and the dilemma rated companies can face. The complex situation in this case results from Sulzer AG’s significant strategic reorientation to industrial activities, a hostile takeover attempt and the product recall at Sulzer Medica, in which, when the recall was launched, it had a majority interest – with the intention of selling it in the near future. Moreover, the case provokes discussion about internal and external effects of the removal from the index, and adequate reactions of Sulzer AG in the short and long term.

Keywords

Sustainability Ratings, Corporate Governance, Product Recall, Crisis Management, Corporate Sustainability Management

Settings

September 2001

Type

Field Research

Available Languages

English

Related material

Teaching note

IMD case studies are distributed through case clearing houses. In order to browse the collection and purchase copies please visit the links below.

The Case Centre

Cranfield University

Wharley End Beds MK43 0JR, UK
Tel +44 (0)1234 750903
Email [email protected]

Harvard Business School Publishing

60 Harvard Way, Boston MA 02163, USA
Tel (800) 545-7685 Tel (617)-783-7600
Fax (617) 783-7666
Email [email protected]

Asia Pacific Case Center

NUCB Business School

1-3-1 Nishiki Naka
Nagoya Aichi, Japan 460-0003
Tel +81 52 20 38 111
Email [email protected]

IMD retains all proprietary interests in its case studies and notes. Without prior written permission, IMD cases and notes may not be reproduced, used, translated, included in books or other publications, distributed in any form or by any means, stored in a database or in other retrieval systems. For additional copyright information related to case studies, please contact Case Services.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Keep reading

Article

Boundary conditions for organizations in the Anthropocene: A review of the planetary boundaries framework 10 years on

We systematically review business research concerning the planetary boundaries framework: A natural science framework that identifies nine Earth system boundaries that govern the safe operating space for humanity. Ten years after the introduction ...

Sustainability

By Amanda Williams, Paolo Perego and Gail Whiteman

in Journal of Management Studies

June 2025, vol. 62, no.4, pp. 1811-1846, https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.13150

Article

Algorithms and ecosystems: AI in biodiversity conservation

The rise of AI-assisted tools will make it easier for businesses to engage with the complexities of nature and its ecosystems and will open up new opportunities for nature-related businesses.

Sustainability Artificial Intelligence

By Adrian Dellecker

in I by IMD

15 May 2025

Case Study

Candles Killer: Lighting up the world at the bottom of the pyramid

Sustainability Customer Centricity Innovation Strategy

By Winter Nie and Yunfei Feng

Article

Five Questions for Executives On Energy Transition

Should you lead or follow, move fast or slow, go it alone or seek partners? Here’s how to get the key decisions right when aiming for a sustainable transformation.

Sustainability

By Amanda Williams and Knut Bjarne Haanaes

in I by IMD

14 May 2025

Article

How to get sustainable business transformation right

Sustainable corporate change is a challenging feat to pull off. Julia Binder examines the barriers and drivers of change to increase your chances of success.

Business Transformation Sustainability

By Julia Katharina Binder

in I by IMD Brain Circuits

12 May 2025

Case Study

The new protein buzz: Can Legendary Foods Africa feed the world with insects

Entrepreneurship Sustainability Social Innovation

By Sophie Bacq, Valerie Keller-Birrer and Ruth Shalom Kinyua

Article

Environmental commitment: Do firms walk the talk? An exploratory study of Italian listed companies

This study investigates whether the recent surge in corporate disclosure of environmental commitment was followed by improvements in corporate environmental performance over time. Focusing on Italian listed companies in the period 2019–2022, the s...

Sustainability

By Sara Ratti, Laura Dell'Agostino, Marika Arena and Giovanni Azzone

in Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management

7 May 2025, ePub before print, https://doi.org/10.1002/csr.3224

Article

Are you using AI for a sustainable future?

As AI continues to reshape industries, businesses must navigate the balance between automation and human contribution. Take this short quiz to test your knowledge of its potential uses and check out our tips on collaborating for a sustainable futu...

Sustainability

By José Parra Moyano

in I by IMD Brain Circuits

7 May 2025

Article

How to leave a sustainable legacy: 5 leadership keys

A five-step approach can help you foster a sustainable legacy while supporting a financially sound future for your organization. James Welch explains how it’s done.

Sustainability Leadership

By James Welch

in I by IMD Brain Circuits

5 May 2025

Article

How to use design thinking to achieve sustainability goals

Implementing sustainability programs is notoriously difficult. Here’s how to use a stakeholder-centered design-thinking approach to boost the chances of successful implementation.

Sustainability

By Morten B. Pedersen and Jan Van der Kaaij

in I by IMD Brain Circuits

28 April 2025

Candles Killer: Lighting up the world at the bottom of the pyramid

By Winter Nie and Yunfei Feng
Case reference: IMD-2661 ©2025

Summary

Shenzhen Power-Solution (SPS), founded in 2009 in China as an entrepreneurial venture, disrupted traditional lighting markets in African villages with its flagship product, Candles Killer. This solar lamp, priced under $5, replaces hazardous kerosene lamps and has an optimized design (9 components, water-bottle stands). The candles killer solar lamp addresses the critical need for affordable, safe and sustainable lighting for people at the bottom of the pyramid (BOP), a huge market that multinationals struggle to reach. By achieving both low cost and differentiation, SPS created a blue ocean market. The company has made remarkable progress in its mission to provide solar lighting to underserved communities: by 2023, it illuminated over 55 million people across 7.8 million households in 66 countries. Beyond social impact, SPS achieved environmental sustainability at scale, reducing cumulative carbon emissions by 6.7 million tons, the equivalent of planting 368 million evergreen trees. Candles Killer's success led SPS to expand its product line into a solar home system for phone charging and multi-bulb lighting. SPS also introduced Solar Media, a platform with pre-loaded content (medical tips, farming methods, education) to share vital knowledge in remote regions.

Reference IMD-2661

Organization Shenzhen Power-Solution

Industry Energy;Utilities, Electricity Supply;Consumer Goods, Consumer Electronics

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications