Board meeting room

Governance

Your legacy as CEO is what happens after you leave

Published November 20, 2026 in Governance • 9 min read

A CEO’s greatest test may come after they step down. Five questions can help boards and business leaders assess whether they have built an organization capable of thriving without them.

Rapid read:

  • A CEO’s legacy cannot be judged entirely during their tenure. What happens after they leave may be a more revealing measure of whether they built an organization capable of succeeding without them.
  • Stepping down does not necessarily mean relinquishing influence. Even well-intentioned involvement can constrain a successor’s decisions, particularly when employees and boards continue to look to the former CEO for direction.
  • Exceptional leaders can create exceptional dependencies. Boards need to recognize when a company’s success rests too heavily on one individual and develop future leaders well before succession becomes an immediate concern.

What does it really mean to leave a lasting legacy as a CEO? Is it the market value of the company, the products developed, or the reputation built over years of leadership? Or is the more revealing measure what happens after you leave?

This isn’t just philosophy. My research with Don Hambrick found that the share of company performance attributable to the individual CEO roughly doubled since the 1950s. CEOs matter more than they used to, and founders sit at the high end. The more a leader matters, the more the handover matters.

And whatever a founder, or any leader, builds only becomes part of the legacy if it survives. The challenge is not simply to choose a successor, but to give that person the authority and freedom to lead.

Consider Jensen Huang, who spent 33 years building Nvidia into a driving force behind the AI revolution. Huang resigned as CEO and left the board in November following disclosures about personal relationships that raised questions about conflicts of interest, and even US national security. His departure has prompted calls for his return from investors, employees, and prominent figures in the technology industry.

Whatever the circumstances of his exit, the challenge for Nvidia is now much bigger than replacing its founder. It is whether a company so closely associated with one individual can continue to thrive without him. Five questions can help departing CEOs and their boards assess whether they have created the conditions for that to happen.

Steve Jobs established Apple University to pass on the company's approach to leadership and decision-making

1 – Did you build a bench capable of replacing you?

A successful succession doesn’t begin when a CEO announces their departure. It depends on the work done years earlier to develop leaders who understand the business and are capable of taking it forward.

For founders, whose knowledge, relationships, and judgment may have shaped a company for decades, that can be particularly difficult. Huang said publicly he didn’t believe in traditional succession planning. His departure has brought the question of how Nvidia develops its future leaders into sharper focus.

Steve Jobs established Apple University to pass on the company’s approach to leadership and decision-making, using case studies to help future executives understand how Apple worked. It was a way of ensuring that some of the knowledge and judgment that had shaped the company would survive its founder.

2 – Have you publicly transferred authority?

Stepping down from a formal position is one thing. Making it clear to everyone that you no longer intend to exercise that authority is another. A board announcement may confirm a change in leadership, but the departing CEO also has a role to play in establishing the legitimacy of their successor.

A compelling example of this dates back more than 200 years. In 1783, having won the Revolutionary War, George Washington resigned his military commission and returned home. King George III reportedly remarked that if Washington gave up power, he would be the greatest man in the world.

Though reluctant, he was eventually persuaded to run for president and won two terms. Then, thirteen years after his first departure, he did it again. In a move made famous by the song from Hamilton titled “One Last Time” with it’s famous line, “We’re going to teach them how to say goodbye,” Washington used his Farewell Address as President, to declare his intention “to decline being considered among the number of those out of whom a choice is to be made.” He didn’t just leave. He publicly took himself out of contention so the next person could lead without a shadow over them. He set a precedent that underpinned the American tradition of a peaceful transfer of power for more than two centuries.

It should be the same with a company and CEO. No matter the circumstances of a departure, the organization needs to hear from the departing CEO, in their own words, that the next leader is in charge. Without that clarity, even a carefully planned succession can leave questions about where authority really lies.

Beautiful mature business woman and her male colleague analyzing report and discussing results while having a meeting with project team
Leaving the CEO role doesn’t necessarily mean a full departure from the firm, though there’s evidence it should more than it does

3 – Have you made your role small enough?

Leaving the CEO role doesn’t necessarily mean a full departure from the firm, though there’s evidence it should more than it does. Staying on as chair is common and often well-meant, particularly when a company wants to preserve continuity. But it can also make it harder for the incoming CEO to establish their authority.

Our research on CEOs who stay on as board chair found their successors make fewer strategic changes and see muted performance gains until the the predecessor departs. Part of that constraint is formal because the chair sets the agenda. Much of it is implicit because it’s hard to undo the predecessor’s ideas while they watch over you. Notably, as soon as the predecessor departs as board chair, there’s a substantial jump in change.

A former CEO’s influence isn’t limited to formal positions. It can persist through an advisory title, phone calls from old lieutenants that might undermine decisions made by the successor, or even a well-meant comment shared at the wrong moment.

The risks become more apparent when a former CEO is seen to be challenging the succession itself. After resigning as Uber’s CEO in 2017, Travis Kalanick remained on the board amid reports that he was seeking a return. An investor subsequently sued, alleging that he was interfering with important decisions, including the search for his successor. While it is still early, Jensen Huang’s statement that he is open to returning to Nvidia is exactly the kind of subtle pressure that can tie a new CEO up in knots just when they need to establish themselves as a new leader. This will make it hard for Nvidia to attract the best candidates and challenging for whoever takes on the role as CEO.

If every choice is judged against what the former leader would have done, the company risks becoming trapped by its own history.

4 – Can the company stop asking what you would have done?

Even when a departing CEO has relinquished formal authority, their influence can linger in the decisions others make. Employees may continue to look to their former leader’s judgment, while successors can find themselves measured against what their predecessor might have done. A new CEO will face circumstances their predecessor never encountered and may need to make decisions that challenge established prior assumptions and rework past strategies. If every choice is judged against what the former leader would have done, the company risks becoming trapped by its own history or paralyzed without the decisiveness of the departed leader. Steve Jobs understood this. Tim Cook has said Jobs told him never to ask what Jobs would have done, because he had watched Disney freeze after Walt Disney’s death, with executives sitting in meetings asking what Walt would have done. Instead, Jobs told Cook to just “do the right thing.”

At first glance, this might seem at odds with the first point above focused on building a bench and infusing the DNA of decision making and judgment deep into the organization. But, reporting on this often gets it wrong. Apple University and related development of Apple’s “bench” isn’t about asking what Jobs would have done. Rather, it’s to perpetuate a way of thinking: focusing on the small number of things that matter, challenging convention, simplifying to the essence, caring about the details, and delivering an amazing customer experience. And the key here is that Jobs created the conditions for his employees to know what the right thing was, even years later as the company faced new challenges Jobs could have only dreamed about.

Jack Welch said his two decades at GE should be judged by the company’s performance over a comparable period under his successors.

5 – Does what you built still work without you?

The ultimate test of succession is whether a company can sustain its achievements after the CEO leaves.

Paul O’Neill, former CEO of Alcoa and later Treasury Secretary, was obsessed with safety and believed that treating employees with dignity and respect was the entry point for getting their best effort. His measure of whether he had mattered at Alcoa was by whether its injury rate kept falling after he was gone.

Jack Welch said his two decades at GE should be judged by the company’s performance over a comparable period under his successors. He acted on it, at least at first. In 2001, he handed Jeff Immelt both the CEO and chair titles and walked away, telling Fortune that Immelt had a board that knew what Welch had done “wraps yesterday’s fish.”

Years later, as his own legacy came under question, Welch publicly criticized his successor, a reminder of how hard it is to stay gone. Both examples raise a question for departing leaders: have they built something that can continue to perform and adapt without their involvement? And can they resist the urge to meddle if the new leader hits a rough patch. My argument is this: if you do the hard work up front, develop a bench of capable leaders, perform a proper handoff of both formal and informal authority, and largely stay out of sight after the new CEO starts, then it’s likely the organization and your legacy will carry on because you made yourself replaceable.

Whoever succeeds Huang risks being judged against one question from employees, investors, and others across the industry: what would Jensen have done?

When a leader becomes a liability

The challenge for any board overseeing a leadership transition is not simply to identify a successor, but to ensure that person has the authority, support, and freedom to lead. That becomes particularly difficult when a company has been so closely associated with one individual that their successor risks being measured against what the former CEO would have done.

Nvidia offers a particularly striking example. Whoever succeeds Huang risks being judged against one question from employees, investors, and others across the industry: what would Jensen have done? Anything that goes wrong may be attributed, rightly or wrongly, to a decision Huang wouldn’t have made. The same romance of leadership that made Huang a legend could make his successor a scapegoat.

When an industry comes to believe one person is its keystone, that is a key-person risk the board should have addressed years ago.

Huang’s first 33 years at Nvidia are already written. The rest of his legacy will be written by someone else, in a company he no longer runs. The one part he can still shape is the shadow he casts over that person and their selection. His first statements, suggesting he is ready to return, is exactly the wrong message to send because it just chased off or at least put on edge many of the most qualified candidates to replace him. Why? Because those same candidates can probably hold out and land somewhere else that isn’t under Jensen Huangs’s shadow.

Authors

Tim Quigley

Professor of Strategic Leadership and Governance

Timothy J. Quigley is Professor of Strategic Leadership and Governance at IMD. His research focuses on corporate governance, CEO succession, executive decision-making, and the factors that shape leadership effectiveness. Quigley helps leaders navigate uncertainty by improving decision processes and addressing the cognitive biases that influence judgment. His work has been published in leading journals, including Strategic Management Journal, Academy of Management Journal, and Organization Science, and featured in major media outlets such as the Financial Times and The Washington Post. Before entering academia, he built a career in consulting and technology, helping organizations leverage emerging digital technologies.

Related

Learn Brain Circuits

Join us for daily exercises focusing on issues from team building to developing an actionable sustainability plan to personal development. Go on - they only take five minutes.
 
Read more 

Explore Leadership

What makes a great leader? Do you need charisma? How do you inspire your team? Our experts offer actionable insights through first-person narratives, behind-the-scenes interviews and The Help Desk.
 
Read more

Join Membership

Log in here to join in the conversation with the I by IMD community. Your subscription grants you access to the quarterly magazine plus daily articles, videos, podcasts and learning exercises.
 
Sign up

Log in or register to enjoy the full experience

Explore first person business intelligence from top minds curated for a global executive audience