HomeResearch & Knowledgeback to HomeSustainabilityback to Research & KnowledgeCoal: Exit, voice or loyalty? The case of three mining multinationalsback to Sustainability

Case Study

Coal: Exit, voice or loyalty? The case of three mining multinationals

By David Bach and Shih-Han Huang

22 pages

June 2023

Order this case study

Reference: IMD-7-2436

Coal plays a critical role as an energy pillar in many parts of the world. In three of the world’s most populous countries – China, India and Indonesia – coal supplies more than 60% of electricity needs. However, coal is also one of the most polluting and greenhouse gas emission-intensive substances, holding the dubious title of the single largest contributor to global warming. Mining is one of the industries under scrutiny for its role in the coal supply chain. Amid growing negative public sentiment and investor pressure, the mining majors are pursuing different strategies regarding coal. Rio Tinto completely exited in 2018. Anglo American spun out its coal assets into a separate company, effectively putting the decision in shareholders’ hands. Meanwhile, Glencore held on to coal, declaring “managed decline” the most responsible approach. The case’s dilemma – “who has it right” – offers fertile ground for debate. Participants should analyze the pros and cons of the company’s strategies from different angles and explore the repercussions on various stakeholders, on shareholders and on the environment. The potential learnings from this case and previews of the difficult trade-offs leaders face extend beyond mining to many industries in transition.

Learning Objective

Analyze the pros and cons of a company’s strategy from different angles (stakeholder, shareholder, environmental, competitive, etc) and the potential ramifications within and beyond the company itself.
Understand the potentially difficult trade-offs leaders face during transitions.
Explain the diversification discount and when companies might want to be diversified despite the associated “discount.”
Recognize the role proactive stakeholder engagement plays in transitions.

Keywords

Disruption, Coal Mining, Corporate Sustainability Management, Competitive Strategy, Risk Management, Responsible Production, Energy, Stakeholder Management, Shareholder Engagement, Shareholder Activism, Clean Energy, Affordable Energy, Climate Action

Settings

World/global
Rio Tinto Group, Glencore, Anglo American, Materials, Metals and Mining
2013-2023

Type

Published Sources

Available Languages

English

Related material

Teaching note

IMD case studies are distributed through case clearing houses. In order to browse the collection and purchase copies please visit the links below.

The Case Centre

Cranfield University

Wharley End Beds MK43 0JR, UK
Tel +44 (0)1234 750903
Email [email protected]

Harvard Business School Publishing

60 Harvard Way, Boston MA 02163, USA
Tel (800) 545-7685 Tel (617)-783-7600
Fax (617) 783-7666
Email [email protected]

Asia Pacific Case Center

NUCB Business School

1-3-1 Nishiki Naka
Nagoya Aichi, Japan 460-0003
Tel +81 52 20 38 111
Email [email protected]

IMD retains all proprietary interests in its case studies and notes. Without prior written permission, IMD cases and notes may not be reproduced, used, translated, included in books or other publications, distributed in any form or by any means, stored in a database or in other retrieval systems. For additional copyright information related to case studies, please contact Case Services.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Keep reading

Case Study

The power of brand-led differentiation: What Vanzetti Engineering learned from luxury brands (B) (Video case)

Luxury Marketing Strategy

By Stéphane J. G. Girod and Martin Králik

Podcast

What if Europe’s biggest risk isn’t war – but running out of power?

In this edition of Leaders Unplugged, IMD President David Bach and Vestas CEO Henrik Andersen discuss Europe’s energy risks and bold leadership.

Leadership Strategy Sustainability Technology Management

By David Bach and Felix Zeltner

in I by IMD

Video

Novonesis CEO’s strategy for sustainable growth I by IMD

Novonesis CEO Ester Baiget shares how the Danish biosolutions leader uses science, AI, and culture to transform food, detergents, and sustainability.

Innovation Sustainability Technology Management

By Jean-François Manzoni

in I by IMD

Article

Philip Morris International Sustainability - Redefining Legacy

Philip Morris International Sustainability explores PMI's shift from cigarettes to smoke-free alternatives, delivering measurable change across global markets.

Sustainability

By Julia Binder and Esther Salvi

in I by IMD

Podcast

Inside the Transition: The outlook for COP 30 and the road ahead

Join Knut Haanaes and Julia Binder with climate negotiator Paul Watkinson as they unpack global challenges and progress in the clean energy transition.

Change Management Disruption Innovation

By Julia Binder and Knut Haanaes

in I by IMD

Article

The Future of Supply Chain

This guide examines the industry priorities and outlines five strategic areas of focus for supply chain transformation in 2025 and beyond.

Strategy Supply Chain

in I by IMD

Case Study

The power of brand-led differentiation: What Vanzetti Engineering learned from luxury brands (A)

Luxury Marketing Strategy

By Stéphane J. G. Girod and Martin Králik

Article

Contrary to what you might have heard, Europe is a 21st-century success story

Listen to the critics and you would think Europe was finished. Too bureaucratic, they say. Cannot agree on migration. Moving at glacial pace while Silicon Valley races ahead. It has become such a tired narrative that we have almost started believi...

Economics Geopolitics Disruption

By Arturo Bris

in Monocle

6 October 2025

Article

No more sugar coating: The Doughnut business leaders can no longer afford to ignore

Updated Doughnut of social and planetary boundaries shows urgent gaps. Businesses must act to balance human needs with a thriving planet.

What can we learn from Xiaomi’s monumental EV rise

Xiaomi’s rapid EV rise shows how future readiness and agility are reshaping the auto industry – a challenge traditional automakers can’t ignore.

Strategy

By Mark J. Greeven

in I by IMD

The power of brand-led differentiation: What Vanzetti Engineering learned from luxury brands (B) (Video case)

By Stéphane J. G. Girod and Martin Králik
Case reference: IMD-2696 ©2025

Summary

This case series explores what companies can learn from luxury brands without becoming luxury brands themselves. The video B case features interviews with three Vanzetti Engineering executives: the marketing director, the CEO and owner and the chief commercial officer. With the shrinking of the automobile industry, the company has had to reposition itself in other industrial sectors where it is significantly smaller than the customers. Vanzetti Engineering embraced some of the codes of luxury branding according to what suited it and ignored others. The company discovered that although it was focused mostly on creating functional value, it had to dwell much more on emotional and societal value creation. The process of brand elevation required a complete cultural transformation, and one of the lessons from the case is that a brand is not a slogan but a way of being and of delivering value.

Reference IMD-2696

Organization Vanzetti Engineering

Industry Construction and Engineering;Manufacturing

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Luxury

Marketing

Strategy

Browse all topics

What if Europe’s biggest risk isn’t war – but running out of power?

By David Bach and Felix Zeltner
in I by IMD

Summary

In this edition of Leaders Unplugged, IMD President David Bach and Vestas CEO Henrik Andersen discuss Europe’s energy risks and bold leadership.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Leadership

Strategy

Sustainability

Technology Management

Browse all topics

Novonesis CEO’s strategy for sustainable growth I by IMD

By Jean-François Manzoni
in I by IMD

Summary

Novonesis CEO Ester Baiget shares how the Danish biosolutions leader uses science, AI, and culture to transform food, detergents, and sustainability.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Innovation

Sustainability

Technology Management

Browse all topics

Inside the Transition: The outlook for COP 30 and the road ahead

By Julia Binder and Knut Haanaes
in I by IMD

Summary

Join Knut Haanaes and Julia Binder with climate negotiator Paul Watkinson as they unpack global challenges and progress in the clean energy transition.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Change Management

Disruption

Innovation

Browse all topics

The power of brand-led differentiation: What Vanzetti Engineering learned from luxury brands (A)

By Stéphane J. G. Girod and Martin Králik
Case reference: IMD-2688 ©2025

Summary

Survey after survey shows that executives think their business is in danger of being commoditized. This means their company is not able to differentiate sufficiently to command higher market prices and profits. Luxury brands, by contrast, are the opposite of commodity. Their whole approach to branding is based on desirability. This case series explores what companies can learn from luxury brands without becoming luxury brands themselves. The written A case gives a short background on Vanzetti Engineering, which is facing intensifying competition in an evolving marketplace, and launches the first question for discussion.

Reference IMD-2688

Organization Vanzetti Engineering

Industry Construction and Engineering;Manufacturing

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Luxury

Marketing

Strategy

Browse all topics

Contrary to what you might have heard, Europe is a 21st-century success story