The key factors to compete in Asia
Asia can be both an engine of growth as well as the source of numerous challenges â from unfamiliar customers and competitors to hard-to-navigate regulations. In this webinar, weâll provide you with...
- YouTube
2 December 2022 ⢠by Patrick Reinmoeller in Videos
Leaders can harness their attention, motivation, capabilities and capacity to link strategy with culture, and reap benefits for every stakeholder....
In many companies, strategy and culture are treated as separate issues, but thinking of them as irreconcilable is misguided, and it often leads to shareholder disappointment. If company leaders get culture right from the start, they will have better strategies and they will execute them more successfully. When culture enables strategy, it becomes a competitive advantage.Â
In a recent LTT webinar Patrick Reinmoeller, Professor of Strategy and Innovation, outlined how leaders can harness their attention, motivation, capabilities and capacity to align strategy with culture, and reap benefits for every stakeholder. He also highlighted how companies which failed to do that have suffered.Â
He drew on examples from the real business world â starting with Twitter. The social media companyâs strategy under new owner Elon Musk may look solid, but Reinmoeller questioned whether the culture being instilled by the billionaire would enable the realization of the strategy.Â
That strategy has been leaked, showing that Musk intends to quintuple revenue to $26.4 billion by 2028, as well as reduce Twitterâs reliance on advertising to under 50% of revenue. The worldâs richest man also wants to reach 931 million users by 2028, with part of the growth coming from a new âTwitter Blueâ subscription service.Â
Further, Musk intends to produce $15 million in revenue from a new payments business. That would move Twitter towards becoming a âsuper-appâ in the mold of Chinaâs WeChat, a ubiquitous application for messaging, payments, e-commerce and more.Â
We see strategy and culture misalign and even great innovators and entrepreneurs like Elon Musk can get it wrong
Yet Reinmoeller questioned the culture emerging under the new owner, who quickly fired more than half of Twitterâs 7,500-strong workforce and saw hundreds more voluntarily quit rather than committing to an âextremely hardcoreâ working culture. Indeed, the professor noted problems emerging at the company, such as the postponement of the relaunch of the subscription service after it was withdrawn because users abused the system and impersonated high-profile brands and individuals.Â
There are also concerns among brands about whether Twitter is a safe place to advertise, Reinmoeller said, given Muskâs past pledges to relax content moderation rules. âSo, we see strategy and culture misalign and even great innovators and entrepreneurs like Elon Musk can get it wrong,â he said, adding that âhaving a war with talent doesnât really make senseâ and âif all those companies say our value comes from our people, then he let go of $22 billion in valueâ when he cut half the $44 billion firmâs workforce.Â
Reinmoeller also pointed out that culture and strategy must work for all stakeholders, drawing on the example of General Electric, the US conglomerate that was previously headed by the storied chief executive Jack Welch. He was renowned for a hard-changing culture, having put in place a firing policy whereby the bottom 10% of the performers were culled every year. The strategy appeared to work, as the company consistently beat earnings estimates.
However, critics have argued that this had wider consequences for society because it destabilized the US middle class and inspired generations of leaders who have emulated his practices at other companies. âWe find alignment between strategy and culture in organizations that generate wealth and prosperity for all, but also companies that generate wealth and prosperity for the few,â said Reinmoeller.
In some instances, the professor said that it was necessary to break-up an organization in order to align strategy and culture. He pointed to EY, the professional services firm that is attempting to separate its audit and consulting businesses in a radical shake-up.
âIf they split auditing and consulting, it is going to be easier to align strategy with the culture,â Reinmoeller explained. âThey have auditors who focus on accuracy and compliance, and consultants who can imagine great solutions. This suggests that a separation is needed in order to have strategies that can be implemented well.â
Though, he noted that the legendary investor Warren Buffettâs Berkshire Hathaway conglomerate had demolished the conventional wisdom on synergies. âYou only need to start thinking about a cohesive culture when you want to generate those synergies,â Reinmoeller pointed out. Â
That said, he added that a bad culture can ruin even the best corporate strategies; they are inseparable. The professor drew on a fresh case study to illustrate his point: Sam Bankman-Fried, whose $32 billion cryptocurrency empire collapsed in specular fashion recently. Reinmoeller noted that Bankman-Friedâs investors were wowed by the cult of the star entrepreneur, and missed failures of corporate governance at Bankman-Friedâs now-bankrupt crypto exchange FTX.Â
It has been said that when he was advised to form a board, Bankman-Fried’s response was: âGo f**k yourself.âÂ
âCulture can take people for a ride,â Reinmoeller commented. âBuying into a specific culture that exemplifies the entrepreneur â rugged, tough, bold, direct-speaking, offensive â is sometimes appreciated. And being [captivated] by such a culture can lead to very unfortunate investment decisions.âÂ
Reinmoeller went on to say that aligning strategy with culture requires paying attention to how both are evolving, as well as the buy-in of every stakeholder. Development of leadership capabilities and capacity at the top of the organization to deal with the contradictions and complexity is critical, too, as it filters down through the workforce. He said that, as stewards of their organizations, leaders are responsible for culture which he defined as: âWhat is done when you, the boss, is not there.â
Professor of Strategy and Innovation at IMD
Patrick Reinmoeller has led public programs on breakthrough strategic thinking and strategic leadership for senior executives, and custom programs for leading multinationals in fast moving consumer goods, telecommunications, pharmaceuticals, healthcare, and energy on developing strategic priorities, implementing strategic initiatives, and managing change. More recently, his work has focused on helping senior executives and company leaders to build capabilities to set and drive strategic priorities.
24 August 2021 ⢠by Mark J. Greeven, Patrick Reinmoeller in Leading in Turbulent Times ⢠5 min read
Asia can be both an engine of growth as well as the source of numerous challenges â from unfamiliar customers and competitors to hard-to-navigate regulations. In this webinar, weâll provide you with...
9 July 2021 ⢠by Karl Schmedders in Leading in Turbulent Times ⢠4 min read
âThe E and the S are competing for attention, and the greener we go, the more social harm we need to account for,â says IMD Professor of Finance Karl Schmedders....
18 June 2021 ⢠by Vanina Farber in Leading in Turbulent Times ⢠4 min read
There is a growing need to provide executives with the tools to takeâŻa more integrated approach to impact and businessâŻâ and to change mindsets when it comes to financial decision-making....
9 June 2021 ⢠by James E. Henderson in Leading in Turbulent Times ⢠4 min read
The once popular model of having a high-level management team develop a strategy which is then communicated to the rest of the organization is quickly becoming archaic. A truly inclusive strategy is...
Explore first person business intelligence from top minds curated for a global executive audience