IMD International

WORKING PAPERS

Leading-edge managerial thinking

The Working Paper Series
IMD has created a series of working papers with the purpose of providing a quick and efficient means of publishing its latest research, concepts and leading-edge managerial thinking.

This series is a reflection of IMD’s vibrant intellectual activity and thought leadership, as well as its contributions to the managerial literature.

The papers are in general documents presented at international conferences, guest speaker presentations, book chapters or articles currently submitted and at various stages in the review process at leading academic journals and publications.

Working paper hard copies are also available from IMD’s Information Center or from the IMD R&D archives.

Information Center


Full text is available for certain Working Papers in PDF format. Please click on the title column of any Working Paper to expand information.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.


Title Description
Healthcare Rationing & Patient Rights
Authors: Ralf Boscheck

Ref. IMD 2004-04, August 2004.

Abstract:
Current healthcare reforms in the US, Germany and the UK, representing significantly different funding conditions, reflect a common interest in market-driven cost containment. Each reform project embraces fixed-price, prospective contracts to deal with shortcomings of the respective current approaches. In each case, economic motives affect clinical autonomy and treatment decisions and limit patients' choice and payers' financial commitment. In each case, cost containment however may also result in unwarranted exclusions from vital cures and generally sub-optimal healthcare supply. Regulatory responses to evident risks differ in substance, each suffering from some acute shortcomings. Yet, in a more general sense the three healthcare projects are similar: In each case, political authorities effectively displace the responsibility for actually "managing care" without having set effective substantive and procedural standards. But quality norms and treatment standards are essential to distinguish proper treatment from malpractice, and the wrongful from the justified denial of service. Clarity about the legal status of managed care organization, contractors and patients is vital in determining the extent and allocation of liabilities, rights and obligations. Murky standards at each level hamper operational and regulatory governance and fuel concerns for legitimacy. If these concerns are self-evident - why are responses to them not patently obvious? As is argued next, the explanation has three elements. (1) Like most OECD countries, the USA, the UK and Germany do not face up to the essence of "managing care." (2.) Dodging the facts has fuelled the delegation of de facto decision-making to healthcare suppliers and manifests itself in a diluted system of governance and cost control. (3.) Growing demand-sides concerns are being "dealt" with through the promotion of patient rights, which, however, de facto are, and for all practical purposes should be, of little legal significance. There may be a right to "healthcare" but there cannot be an inalienable right to treatment. The question is how to advance from the current state of affairs.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Healthcare Reforms & Governance Concerns The Cases of the United States, the United Kingdom and Germany
Authors: Ralf Boscheck

Ref. IMD 2004-05, August 2004.

Abstract:
Average healthcare costs in OECD countries, upon having risen from 5% of GDP in 1970 to 8.4% of GDP in 2001, are presently estimated to grow at 5% annually. And yet, as Table 1 indicates, increases in spending do not necessarily translate into higher levels of service or more equal access to it. Nor do more outlays automatically improve a nation's general health status, clinical outcomes or process of care. Hence, countries with rather different institutional structures and spending levels, exhausting conventional funding opportunities and missing out on otherwise important expenditures, have put healthcare reforms on top of their domestic policy agendas. In each case, the goal is to build a sustainable financial foundation and to contain costs by testing patient needs and efficacious treatment patterns. In each case, determining cost-effective therapies as a condition for coverage amounts to 'managing care' raises concerns about the legitimacy and contestability of results and standards and points to growing problems of healthcare governance. This article cuts across the debate to identify common patterns and potential challenges. Section 1 presents a typology of healthcare systems based on funding methods and supply contracts and, challenging often presumed performance differences, points to the need for detailed case analysis. Section 2 presents healthcare reforms in the structurally very different US, UK and German systems. In each case, incentive contracts, to deal with shortcomings of the current approach, evoke regulatory concerns. Summing up each country's policy responses, section 3 exposes a common governance challenge: the need for explicit rationing standards and clear patient rights.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Reliability and Validity of the Fortune Reputation Survey: Measuring Innovativeness and Quality
Authors: Vladimir Pucik and Hee-Jae Cho

Ref. IMD 2004-06, September 2004.

Abstract:
This study examines the reliability and validity of two scores in the Fortune Corporate Reputation Survey (FRS): Innovativeness and Quality of Products/Services. In spite of the strong correlation between Innovativeness and Quality scores of FRS, the two appear to tap different dimensions of corporate reputation. The findings of the results provide evidence of reliability and validity of the FRS database.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Working paper hard copies are available from IMD’s Information Center or from the IMD R&D archives. For Working Papers not available in full text, please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.

Full text is available for certain Working Papers in PDF format. Please click on the title column of any Working Paper to expand information.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.

Title Description
Leadership Effectiveness and Integrity: Wishful Thinking?
Authors: Robert Hooijberg and Nancy Lane

Ref. IMD 2005-01, January 2005.

Abstract:
Some researchers argue that leaders need integrity to be effective, while others argue that only results matter, not how you get them. Few have empirically examined the impact of integrity on leadership effectiveness. We examine the impact of leadership behaviors on effectiveness as well as values such as integrity, flexibility and conformity, using a sample of top-level public service managers. We find that the values of Integrity and Flexibility have a significant impact on effectiveness over and above the impact of various leadership behaviors: Integrity for managers and their peers and flexibility for direct reports and peers.
Full text (PDF, 176KB)

Leveraging Information Locally and Globally: The Right Mix of Flexibility and Standardization
Authors: William J. Kettinger and Donald A. Marchand

Ref. IMD 2005-02, March 2005.

Abstract:
When globalizing their companies senior managers are confronted with a perplexing problem: How do you grow in a way that maximizes local customer value and at the same time minimize enterprise-wide operational costs? Some senior executives seem to address this problem with grace, in essence, "changing the tablecloth without disturbing the cutlery," while others irreparably disturb a company’s delicate balance sending it into an uncoordinated tailspin. Not surprisingly, most executives see promise in the “right” configuration of local and global capabilities and greater use of IT as a way to leverage information and coordinate far flung global operations – but what does this actually mean in terms of a company’s approach to business flexibility and business standardization?
Full text (PDF, 168KB)

Healthcare Reforms & Governance Concerns: The Cases of the United States, the United Kingdom and Germany
Authors: Ralf Boscheck

Ref. IMD 2005-03, March 2005.

Abstract:
Average healthcare costs in OECD countries, upon having risen from 5% of GDP in 1970 to 8.4% of GDP in 2001, are presently estimated to grow at 5% annually.1 And yet, as Table 1 indicates, increases in spending do not necessarily translate into higher levels of service or more equal access to it. Nor do more outlays automatically improve a nation’s general health status, clinical outcomes or process of care. Hence, countries with rather different institutional structures and spending levels, exhausting conventional funding opportunities and missing out on otherwise important expenditures, have put healthcare reforms on top of their domestic policy agendas. In each case, the goal is to build a sustainable financial foundation and to contain costs by testing patient needs and efficacious treatment patterns. In each case, determining cost-effective therapies as a condition for coverage amounts to ‘managing care’ raises concerns about the legitimacy and contestability of results and standards and points to growing problems of healthcare governance. This article cuts across the debate to identify common patterns and potential challenges. Section 1 presents a typology of healthcare systems based on funding methods and supply contracts and, challenging often presumed performance differences, points to the need for detailed case analysis. Section 2 discusses healthcare reforms in the structurally very different US, UK and German systems. In each case, incentive contracts, to deal with shortcomings of the current approach, evoke regulatory concerns. Summing up each country's policy responses, section 3 exposes a range of common governance challenges that market-driven healthcare reforms would need to address.
Full text (PDF, 176KB)

Knowledge Management and Corporate Renewal
Authors: Bala Chakravarthy and Sue McEvily

Ref. IMD 2005-06, May 2005.

Abstract:
This article is about continuous corporate renewal, where a firm seeks to improve its operational excellence even as it explores for new markets and competencies. It explains that the process of renewal mirrors that of knowledge management. The corresponding activities are protecting, leveraging and building knowledge. The article describes these activities and illustrates them with three recent examples. These are from Best Buy (the leading North American retailer of consumer electronics products), Pearson (a leading UK based media giant) and Dr. Reddy’s (a leading generics drug company based in India). It then goes on to describe three key executive actions that can help corporate renewal. Each of the three actions, setting a daring vision, making flexible commitments and balancing organizational power are once again illustrated with the help of the three examples.
Full text (PDF, 184KB)

Understanding Persistently Variable Performance in Plants
Authors: Robert S. Collins and Roger W. Schmenner

Ref. IMD 2005-07, March 2005.

Abstract:
This paper documents the extent to which plant performance varies over an extended period of time, with some plants performing persistently well and sister plants performing persistently poorly. It examines why this phenomenon occurs. It does so by interviews and surveys of senior manufacturing executives who oversee multiple plants. The interview and survey results are consistent with one another and point to the importance of the "mentality" of a plant’s management and workforce: how they think about the factory and its operations. The nature of that mentality is explored.
Full text (PDF, 176KB)

Smart Big Moves
Authors: Paul Strebel

Ref. IMD 2005-08, May 2005.

Abstract:
Big strategic moves are said to be high risk. And yet some companies pull them off successfully, while others flounder, often fatally. Mastering the difference, making big moves with low risk, is essential for value creation in the long run, because incremental growth never lasts forever. To find out how some companies succeed with big moves, while others don’t, we studied pairs of successful and less successful large companies from a variety of industries and home markets, to see how they managed their big moves over the last fifteen years. Big moves were strategic shifts involving a major reallocation of organizational effort and/or financial resources.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

High-Impact Learning Scripts
Authors: Paul Strebel and Tracey Keys

Ref. IMD 2005-09, May 2005.

Abstract:
This paper focuses on the drivers of high-impact learning experiences for executives. Based on the most successful IMD sessions and programs with over 80 companies in 2004, it offers a new way to define and manage the process of great learning, by identifying the common factors underpinning many great learning experiences. These drivers are:

  • Emotional highs: the explicit engagement of executives at an emotional as well as an intellectual level. Going beyond the “comfort zone” is critical to opening executives to new perspectives, while positive emotions provide a foundation for retaining and applying learning in future.
  • Energizing roles: the active management of relationships and roles among the participants and the educator to develop the interactions required for learning. Placing the learner at the heart of the experience and changing roles to create energy and sharing fosters deeper learning.
  • Real world context: the reflection of “real” business challenges that executives are facing daily in the content and context of the learning process. Relevance drives engagement, as well as retention and application of learning. It requires deep understanding of the executives and the business environment to create situations and content that participants can relate to effectively.
  • 3-Dimensional learning: learning experiences designed around intellectual awareness, emotional awareness and action-based application. All three dimensions are required to embed learning. Using many different approaches and stimuli helps to accelerate this process.

These drivers need to be brought together to meet specific executive development needs with a "learning script". Great learning scripts resemble theatrical scripts in that they comprise a series of parts (or acts), each with associated content, activities and roles. Orchestrating a great learning experience requires insight, method and art – and each needs to be customized to specific executive development needs. This represents a new approach to executive education that involves a broad, holistic approach to developing the whole person. High-impact learning generates changes in attitudes, beliefs and behaviours – and is applied to generate positive impact in the workplace. The basic phases in such learning draw on the work on many learning theories, even if the terminology, sequences and some of the underlying rationales vary. However, this paper does not explore learning theory in depth since the nature of learning is fluid and its exact mechanics remain obscure despite neurological breakthroughs, because every person is unique. The insights in this paper are aimed at both executives and educators. For executives the value is in understanding better what makes for an effective learning experience to allow informed choice of the most appropriate process for each person. For educators, it articulates, probably for the first time, the critical factors that underpin “learning that sticks”.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

The Role of the Board of Directors in Shaping Corporate Culture: Reactive Compliance or Visionary Leadership?
Authors: Daniel R. Denison and Caroline Fisher

Ref. IMD 2005-15, July 2005.

Abstract:
This paper, written for a June 2005 conference in the USA, examines the role of the Board of Directors in shaping corporation culture. Prior to the implementation of the Sarbanes-Oxley act in the USA, non-executive board members could remain quite removed from internal issues such as culture. The Post-SOX world now at least requires reactive compliance. In top performing companies, however, board members as well as top executives tend to view corporate culture as an important source of competitive advantage. This paper reviews different perspectives on the issue and makes the case that board members should be involved.
Full text (PDF, 168KB)

EU Constitutional Governance : Failure as Opportunity!?
Authors: Ralf Boscheck

Ref. IMD 2005-16, November 2005.

Abstract:
On June 17th 2005, the European Union summit broke up in a bitter dispute over the EU’s budget and the future of its constitution. Arguments about the union’s financial plans, even sullen accusations of national egoism, have been a usual element of European politics for years. But the popular rejection of the proposed EU constitution by France and the Netherlands, two major advocates of European unity, just prior to the meeting had raised deep questions about the union’s legitimacy and purpose. Hopes by some that successful ratifications in the remaining EU countries would change the French and Dutch stance were soon dispelled. Already at the summit, the Dutch prime minister announced that his country would not vote again on the same, un-amended document; Denmark, Portugal, Ireland, Britain and the Czech Republic put their referendum schedule on hold. Nearly fifty-five years since the beginning of the European voyage, attempts to reach the EU’s "final and natural constitutional destiny" appeared to have thrown the union off course and into "one of the deepest crisis in its history.Or, is Europe facing a unique opportunity for political, economic and institutional renewal?
Full text (PDF, 120KB)

Knowing what to do and doing what you know : Effectuation as a form of entrepreneurial expertise
Authors: Stuart Read and Saras Sarasvathy

Ref. IMD 2005-17, November 2005.

Abstract:
Entrepreneurship has traditionally been studied either as a set of psychological characteristics, or as a residual of environmental structures such as social networks. In line with more recent process views, we propose the study of entrepreneurship as a form of expertise – i.e., a set of skills, models and processes that can be acquired with time and deliberate practice. The framework we build draws upon the literature on expertise in cognitive science, psychology, and decision-making, and relates it to effectuation theory. The paper delineates the domain of entrepreneurial expertise and demarcates the role of deliberate practice within it; demonstrates the efficacy of effectuation as a theory about entrepreneurial expertise; and develops testable propositions about the role of effectual action in the development of entrepreneurial expertise and firm growth.
Full text (PDF, 192KB)

Prediction and control under uncertainty : Strategy in New Venture Investing
Authors: Robert Wiltbank, Stuart Read, Nicholas Dew and Saras Sarasvathy

Ref. IMD 2005-18, November 2005.

Abstract:
Decision theory prescribes investing in prediction as a way to control future outcomes. However, favorable outcomes can also be achieved through control strategies that directly resolve uncertainties. We empirically investigate the orthogonal nature of prediction and control as paths to success in the new venture investment setting. Results show that control-oriented strategies may limit downside risk without compromising the potential for high returns.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Effectual Reasoning in Entrepreneurial Expertise : Existence and Bounds
Authors: Saras Sarasvathy, Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2005-19, November 2005.

Abstract:
This study investigates recent theorizing in entrepreneurship that proposed effectuation as a dominant decision model in entrepreneurial decision making. Think aloud protocols were extracted from 27 expert entrepreneurs and 37 novices who were asked to identify the market for a single new product. A combination of quantitative and qualitative analysis establishes the existence of effectual reasoning in the cognitive processes of expert entrepreneurs and delineates the bounds between their use of causation and effectuation. In quantitative terms, 89% of experts used effectuation more frequently than causation, while novices demonstrated a noticeably opposing preference, with 81% using causation more than effectuation.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Non-Predictive Strategy and New Venture Performance : A Meta-Analysis

 

Authors: Stuart Read and Michael Song

Ref. IMD 2005-20, November 2005.

Abstract:
Despite academic interest in entrepreneurship, research in the area has been criticized for a lack of theoretical grounding. This paper attempts to consolidate entrepreneurial study by applying the theoretical foundation of effectuation to the issue of new venture performance and integrating contemporary entrepreneurship research using meta-analytic techniques. We find effectual constructs positively related to new venture performance suggesting that effectuation in specific, and non-predictive strategies in general, may offer useful insight into new venture success. We close with a critique of our work, presenting an agenda for elevating research to a level commensurate with the best efforts in management.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

DINAM: Direct and Indirect Network Externalities Adoption Model
Authors: Michael Song and Stuart Read

Ref. IMD 2005-21, November 2005.

Abstract:
The economics literature models product adoption by measuring the network externalities of product installed base, availability of complementary product, and price. The diffusion of innovations literature uses consumer perceptions of innovation attributes. The two views are integrated into a model of network externality product adoption that is tested using DVD player data from 204 households over a two-year period.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

The Role of Interorganizational Coordination in Market Formation
Authors: Nicholas Dew and Stuart Read

Ref. IMD 2005-22, November 2005.

Abstract:
The purpose of this work is to develop a systematic understanding of the role of interorganizational coordination in market formation. Based on qualitative research in the RFID (radio frequency identification industry) I identify how a diverse interorganizational community organized around the MIT Auto ID Center coordinated the adoption of an information systems innovation, the EPC (electronic product code). I present a parsimonious model of the causes of coordination problems and the mechanisms organizations use to solve them.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Outlines of a Behavioral Theory of the Entrepreneurial Firm
Authors: Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read, Saras Sarasvathy and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2005-23, November 2005.

Abstract:
In A Behavioral Theory of the Firm (BTF), Cyert and March (1963) present a clutch of ideas for explaining the behavior of established firms within an environment of well-defined markets, stakeholder relationships, technologies, etc. In this paper, we outline a behavioral theory of the entrepreneurial firm that emphasizes transforming environments rather than acting within extant ones. In particular, we explicate three ideas that parallel key concepts in BTF: (1) accumulating stakeholder commitments under goal ambiguity (in line with a political conception of goals), (2) achieving control (as opposed to managing expectations) through non-predictive strategies; and, (3) predominately exaptive (rather than adaptive) orientation.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

The Moderating Role of Expertise on the Relationship Between Involvement and Performance : An Escalation of Commitment Perspective
Authors: Stuart Read, Michael Song and Warren Boeker

Ref. IMD 2005-24, November 2005.

Abstract:
The literature has shown how escalation of commitment can bias decision-making, but very little is known about moderators to the phenomenon. In the venture capital setting, the authors examine venture investors’ involvement in portfolio firms to show that experience and specialization can dramatically impact the relationship between escalation of commitment and performance. In addition to building theory, the authors uncover differences in the nature of involvement, offer new directions for escalation of commitment research, and make practical recommendations.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Immortal Firms in Mortal Markerts? How Entrepreneurs deal with "The Innovator's Dilemma"
Authors: Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read, Saras Sarasvathy and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2005-25, November 2005.

Abstract:
"The Innovators’ Dilemma" consists in the fact that by doing the right thing – i.e., listening to current customers, leading firms often end up losing their markets to upstart newcomers. Therefore, understanding how entrepreneurs successfully create such upstart firms and new markets ought to have direct implications for strategic management theorizing about this dilemma. This paper examines such implications of some recent developments in entrepreneurship and outlines how effectual reasoning may be used to overcome the innovators’ dilemma in large corporations. The paper also identifies new questions for future research in the overlap between strategic management and entrepreneurship.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

What Effectuation is not: Further Development of an Alternative to Rational Choice
Authors: Saras Sarasvathy, Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2005-26, November 2005.

Abstract:
The theory of effectual reasoning advanced by Sarasvathy (2001a) proposes a decision process employed by entrepreneurs that differs substantially from the rational choice paradigm. This paper seeks to clarify this distinctive point of view on entrepreneurial decision-making by pointing to nine things that effectuation is not. The paper further explains the effectual paradigm and illustrates how effectuation integrates with other theories used in management science.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

What to do Next? The Case for Non-Predictive Strategy
Authors: Robert Wiltbank, Nicholas Dew, Saras Sarasvathy and Stuart Read

Ref. IMD 2005-27, November 2005.

Abstract:
Two prescriptions dominate the topic of what firms should do next in uncertain situations; planning approaches and adaptive approaches. These differ primarily on the appropriate role of prediction in the decision process. Prediction is a central issue in strategy making due to the presumption that what can be predicted can be controlled. In this paper we argue for the independence of prediction and control, that the pursuit of successful outcomes can occur through either predictive or control oriented approaches. We further develop and highlight control oriented approaches to open new avenues for dealing with the uncertainty inherent to the question of what organizations should do next. These approaches significantly impact the costs and risk of firm strategy as well as their innovative efforts.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Quantifying Economic Effects of Corporate Sustainability Initiatives - Activities and Drivers
Authors: Oliver Salzmann, Ulrich Steger and Aileen Ionescu-Somers

Ref. IMD 2005-28, November 2005.

Abstract:
Effects of corporate sustainability management are of great interest to both companies and society. In particular, its micro-level economic effects are often the subject of debates and studies discussing the importance and robustness of a business case for corporate sustainability. Obviously these effects are of major importance to promoters and critics of CSM, so is their quantification. Based on recent empirical evidence, we will describe how important and common quantification is and what its drivers and effects are.
Full text (PDF, 448KB)

Managing Attraction in Customer-Supplier Partnerships
Authors: Carlos Cordon, Thomas E. Vollmann and Kim Sundtoft Hald

Ref. IMD 2005-29, December 2005.

Abstract:
A company’s performance is increasingly influenced by the effectiveness of its supply chain, particularly by working with the best suppliers. Similarly, working effectively with the best customers ensures that the overall value chain will be very competitive. A well managed company, is aware of the need to develop close coordination with key suppliers and key customers with the objective of jointly increasing value and decreasing cost in the overall supply chain. Information gathering and model building are the classic tactics normally used to achieve this result. In this article, we present a third tactic, development of attraction in dyadic relationships. With some theoretical underpinnings in social exchange as well as the literature focusing on long-term orientation in customer-supplier partnerships and customer-supplier partnership value, we have developed a conceptual model highlighting three major components of attraction: the perception of expected value gained from the dyadic relationship, the influence of comfort on the effectiveness of the relationship, and the role of relative dependence perception between the dyad partners. We then show how these components interact, and finally discuss how one might better manage the interaction.
Full text (PDF, 184KB)

A Breakdown of the Valuation Effects of International Cross-Listing
Authors: Arturo Bris, Salvatore Cantale and George Nishiotis

Ref. IMD 2005-30, November 2005.

Abstract:
It is well known that cross-listing domestic stocks in foreign exchanges has significant valuation effects on the listed company’s shares. The literature has associated these effects with improvements in liquidity and governance, removal of barriers to investment, and better access to capital and product markets. We use a data set of firms with dual class shares that list only one class in the U.S. We characterize the two classes in terms of liquidity, ownership restrictions and voting characteristics. Consequently we can separate econometrically the different effects of the crosslisting. Our results are consistent with the ADR improving the liquidity in the domestic market and the access of foreign investors to the firm. We deem the effects of improving investor protection as economically small, and we do not find evidence that the valuation impact of the cross-listing is related to better access to foreign markets. Overall, our results explain why less and less firms are willing to list in the U.S.: Sarbanes Oxley has increased the cost of adopting better governance while its benefits are not substantial; ADRs become illiquid a few months after the listing; and market segmentation has decreased significantly in the last years.
Full text (PDF, 376KB)

A Theory of Optimal Expropriation, Mergers and Industry Competition

 

Authors: Arturo Bris and Neil Brisley

Ref. IMD 2005-31, November 2005.

Abstract:
We model a competitive industry where managers choose quantities and costs to maximize a combination of firm profits and private benefits from expropriation. Expropriation is possible because of corporate governance ‘slack’ permitted by the government. We show that corporate governance slack induces managers to choose levels of output and costs that are higher than would otherwise be optimal. This, in turn, benefits consumers because the equilibrium price is lower. The model shows that for every economic system, and depending on industry structure and the government’s objective, there is an optimal level of expropriation that maximizes social welfare. Some mechanisms suggested by the literature as effective at improving investor protection–legal change, firms voluntarily opting into more protective systems, domestic mergers–do not work once competition is considered. We provide a theoretical argument showing the efficacy of cross-border mergers. The stronger corporate governance of a foreign acquirer, imposed on the domestic target firm, benefits merging shareholders and those of competing unmerged domestic firms.
Full text (PDF, 344KB)

The Dynamics of Large and Small Chapter 11 Cases: An Empirical Study
Authors: Douglas Baird, Arturo Bris and Ning Zhu

Ref. IMD 2005-32, November 2005.

Abstract:
This paper shows that the dynamics of Chapter 11 turn dramatically on the size of the business. The vast majority of the assets administered in Chapter 11 are concentrated in a handful of large cases, but most of the businesses in Chapter 11 are small, and the smaller the business, the smaller the distribution to general unsecured creditors. For businesses with assets above $5 million, unsecured creditors typically collect half of what they are owed. Where the business’s assets are worth less than $200,000, ordinary general creditors usually recover nothing. In the typical small Chapter 11 case, the tax collector is the central figure. In small business bankruptcies, priority tax liabilities are the largest unsecured liabilities of the business. Tax obligations are entitled to priority and are obligations of both the corporation and those who run it. Given the large shadow tax claims cast over small Chapter 11 reorganizations, accounts of small Chapter 11 must focus squarely on them.
Full text (PDF, 408KB)

Working paper hard copies are available from IMD’s Information Center or from the IMD R&D archives. For Working Papers not available in full text, please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.


Full text is available for certain Working Papers in PDF format. Please click on the title column of any Working Paper to expand information.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.

Title Description
Shifting Paradigms in Sustainability Management : Instrumental and Value-Driven Orientations

 

Authors: Catherine A. Ramus and Karin Oppegaard

Ref. IMD 2006-01, January 2006.

Abstract:
The authors describe a shift from the traditional approach to sustainability management in companies, which motivates employees using instrumental arguments, external performance criteria and goals, compliance, and control, toward an approach that acknowledges that some employees care about environmental and social outcomes independently of the potential benefits to the company. A value-based management approach results in employees acting responsibly toward the environment and society based upon their self-espoused values, encouraging discretionary behavior and personal effort for sustainability. The authors conceptualize how a dual management system, using both instrumental and value-based orientations, can function in order to encourage both intrinsically and extrinsically motivated employees to work toward sustainability.
Full text (PDF, 104KB)

Relaxing Channel Separation –Integrating a Virtual Store into the Supply Chain via Transshipments
Authors: Ralf W. Seifert, Ulrich W. Thonnemann and Marcel A. Sieke
Ref. IMD 2006-02, May 2006.

Abstract:
Many established companies have started to use virtual stores as a direct distribution channel in addition to their existing indirect retail channels. These companies must now decide how to integrate these channels. The alternatives are to operate dedicated distribution channels for the virtual store and the retail stores or to tightly integrate the virtual store into the existing distribution channels. In such an integrated supply chain, retail stores would continue to serve all in-store customers, but excess stock at retail stores could be used to fill some online orders. We analyze this problem from a supplychain perspective by developing and solving mathematical models for a dedicated and an integrated supply chain. We characterize the optimal inventory policy and quantify the expected cost savings that can be achieved by an integrated supply chain over a dedicated supply chain. We show that the cost savings can be significant and that both retailers and customers benefit from an integrated supply chain. We also analyze how the optimal solutions depend on the characteristics of the supply chain and identify conditions under which it would be optimal to operate the virtual store without dedicating any inventory to the virtual store. Throughout the paper, we illustrate our analytical results with numerical examples.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)
The Impact of Expertise in the Escalation of Commitment - Performance Relationship
Authors: Stuart Read, Michael Song and Warren Boeker

Ref. IMD 2006-03, April 2006.

Abstract:
The literature has cataloged more than twenty determinants of escalation of commitment, but has considered only one view of what happens afterwards. The authors build knowledge around the phenomenon by constructing theory to understand the relationship between escalation of commitment and performance outcomes. The authors identify expertise as a moderator and demonstrate its impact in the setting of venture capital investing. In addition, the authors explore escalation of commitment in terms of time devoted to a project, uncover differences in the nature of that involvement, offer new directions for escalation of commitment research, and make practical recommendations.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

The EU Water Framework Directive: Meeting the Global Call for Regulatory Guidance?
Author: Ralf Boscheck
Ref. IMD 2006-04, September 2006.

Abstract:
The growth in global water withdrawal over the last decade, extrapolated for hundred years to come, results in an annual extraction of twenty-three times the current level. But already the present yearly use of around 5000km3 represents more than half of the amount readily available to humans; this resource is unequally distributed around the globe and seriously compromised by environmental degradation. To arrest this development, UN members, at the Johannesburg Summit in 2002, agreed to employ method of efficient river-basin management by 2005, and in March 2006, at a meeting of water legislators during the 4th World Water Forum, declared water to be “a property of the public domain” and access to it, possibly a human right.
Full text (PDF, 56KB)
Energy Futures – IMD Research Conference 2005
Author: Ralf Boscheck
Ref. IMD 2006-05, September 2006.

Abstract:
Despite prices of around $70 a barrel, the world is experiencing the fastest growth in oil demand in more than 25 years. Windfall profits rise, as do concerns about macro and microeconomic implications. What will be the effects on growth, investments and inflation in net-importer and producer countries? What will be the impact on sluggish exploration activities, reserve replacements, capacity expansions and hence energy supply? Will national resource owners adjust their development strategies? Are entirely new business models required? Will markets and regulatory initiatives deliver effective fuel substitution? To address some of these issues, IMD organized a research conference entitled “Energy Futures” in November 2005. Eighteen international energy researchers, policy makers and executives discussed specific aspects of today’s energy industry and its likely evolution. This introduction briefly sketches various factors shaping our energy future in order to organize the conference contributions and express a common concern.
Full text (PDF, 168KB)
Assessing "New" Upstream Business Models
Author: Ralf Boscheck
Ref. IMD 2006-06, September 2006.

Abstract:
Observers of current upstream oil and gas developments often equate a change in a company’s strategy with a fundamental shift in its underlying business model. But they hardly ever reason the need for new business models based on an explanation of existing ones, their contexts and required modification. This chapter attempts to do just that. Following a brief discussion of the notion of a business model in general and in the context of upstream oil and gas activities, the chapter describes types of upstream players – global majors, independents, contractors and technical service suppliers, NOCs and host country governments – and the characteristic challenges each of them faces. It then proceeds, for each group, to discuss the case of a particular strategy that may be considered to be novel and mould-breaking. An admittedly cursory assessment of the strategies pursued by BP, Spinnaker, Anadarko, Baker Energy, Petrofac, Halliburton and Schlumberger, as well as the UK government in managing the UKCS fiscal regime, does not identify any new or need for new business models. In fact, players seem to develop their given models in line with fairly conventional and even predictable patterns of industry evolution.
Full text (PDF, 376KB)
Overcoming Risk Avoidance Through the Size and Depth of Experience: Top Management Tenure and Investment Timing Decisions
Authors: James Henderson and Karel Cool

Ref. IMD 2006-07, November 2006.

Abstract:
This paper examines how long tenured top management teams may overcome risk avoidance or the commitment to the status quo through the size and depth of their industry experience. This research question is applied to investment bandwagon behavior. There may be several reasons for firms to bunch their capacity expansions or “hop on an investment bandwagon.” These reasons include coordinating through maintaining market shares, information effects and decision-making biases and longtenured top management teams. Yet long tenured top management teams with vivid and deep memories of past expansions may better foresee when they should commence a new expansion. Based on an empirical analysis 35 US headquartered companies operating in the worldwide petrochemicals industry from 1982 – 1995, the results indicate that executive team tenure exhibits both risk avoidance and experience through a curvilinear relationship. However, this curvilinear relationship is moderated by depth rather than size of the top management team’ past expansion experience.
Full text (PDF, 216KB)

Resolving the Commitment versus Flexibility Trade-off: The Role of Resource Accumulation Lags
Authors: Gonçalo Pacheco de Almeida, James Henderson and Karel Cool

Ref. IMD 2006-08, November 2006.

Abstract:
The authors examine how time-consuming resource accumulation influences the classic strategy trade-off between commitment and flexibility. In particular, using data from the worldwide petrochemical industry during the period 1975 to 1995, the authors study the impact of new plants’ time-to-build on firms’ decisions to invest under uncertainty. The authors' results suggest a nontrivial inverted-U shape effect of resource accumulation lags on investment. Contradicting conventional wisdom, the authors show that competition may be fiercer in industries where firms accumulate resources more slowly and that uncertainty is not always a disincentive for investment.
Full text (PDF, 360KB)

 

The Challenge of Sustainable Consumption and the Role of Business as a Solution
Authors: Oliver Salzmann, Heike Leitschuh Fecht, Ulrich Steger and Aileen Ionescu-Somers

Ref. IMD 2006-09, November 2006.

Abstract:
The present paper aims to highlight the challenge of sustainable consumption and to explore the contributions businesses and their multiple stakeholders can make to meet the challenge. It is the result of a comprehensive literature research and a multi-stakeholder dialogue involving managers from various companies, NGOs and researchers. For the purposes of this paper, the authors define sustainable consumption as a behavior pattern of consumers/private households in relation to products and services that puts less strain – over the entire product and service life cycle (essentially purchase, use and disposal/recycling) – on global, regional or local environmental and social systems than alternative patterns.
Full text (PDF, 144KB)

Corporate Governance Convergence Through Cross-Border Mergers: The Case of Aventis
Authors: Arturo Bris and Christos Cabolis

Ref. IMD 2006-10, November 2006.

Abstract:
In this paper the authors illustrate the role of cross-border mergers in the process or corporate governance convergence. The authors explore in detail the corporate governance provisions in Rhône-Poulenc, a French company, and Hoechst, a German firm, and the resulting structure after the two firms merged in 1999 to create Aventis, legally a French corporation. The authors show that, despite the nationality of the firm, the corporate governance structure of Aventis is a combination of the governance systems of Hoechst and Rhône-Poulenc, where the newly merged firm adopted the most protective provisions of the two merging firms. In some case this resulted in Aventis' borrowing from the corporate governance structure of Hoechst while in others Aventis replicated Rhône-Poulenc's structure. Most interesting is the situation where Aventis introduced improved provisions over both systems. The resulting corporate governance system in Aventis is significantly more protective then the default French legal system of investor protection.
Full text (PDF, 1MB)

Designing Organizations that Design Environments : Lessons from Entrepreneurial Expertise
Author: Stuart Read

Ref. IMD 2006-11, December 2006.

Abstract:
Human artifacts lie on the interface between their inner environments and their outer environments. Organizations, therefore, are apt subjects to be studied through a science of the artificial. Furthermore, organizational design happens at two interfaces: first, at the interface between organizational founder/s and the firms they design, and second, between the firms and the environments in which they operate. The author uses recent developments in the study of entrepreneurial expertise to show why an effectual logic of design is necessary at the first interface, and what its consequences are for designing at the second. In particular, the author uses the exemplar case of Starbucks to codify three key characteristics of the design problem at the first interface – namely, Knightian uncertainty, goal ambiguity, and environmental isotropy. The author then uses an “alternate histories” method to trace four strategic options – namely, planning, adaptation, vision, and transformation -- for designing at the second interface. In the final analysis, organizational design is important because effectuators using transformational approaches not only design organizations, but concurrently end up designing the environments we live in.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Do Relative Advantage and Trialability Mediate the Relationships between Network Externalities and Adoption?
Authors: Michael Song, Mark E. Parry and Stuart Read

Ref. IMD 2006-12, December 2006.

Abstract:
In this paper the authors examine the relationship between the network externalities and new product adoption literatures by proposing a series of hypotheses that permit them to test whether consumer perceptions of relative advantage and trialability mediate the relationships between product adoption and (1) the size of the installed base and (2) the availability of complementary products. After reviewing the network externalities literature we identified DVD players as a product category where network externalities should influence consumer adoption. To test their hypotheses the authors collected data through consumer surveys and through two censuses of local video store outlets and DVD retailers. Based on their application of the Baron and Kenny (1986) methodology for identifying mediating variables, the authors conclude that relative advantage does not mediate the relationship between the probability of DVD player adoption and either the perceived size of the installed base or the number of DVD titles available at local video rental stores. The authors also conclude that trialability does not mediate the relationship between the perceived size of the installed base and the probability of adoption, but does mediate the relationship between the number of DVD titles and the probability of adoption.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Effectual Entrepreneurial Expertise : Existence and Bounds
Authors: Saras D. Sarasvathy, Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2006-13, December 2006.

Abstract:
Recent theorizing in entrepreneurship has proposed effectuation as a baseline model of entrepreneurial expertise that goes beyond the “toolbox” of basic business skills such as market research and business planning. This study seeks to empirically delineate key elements of entrepreneurial expertise as compared with basic business knowledge. Think aloud protocols were extracted from 27 expert entrepreneurs and 37 MBA students who were asked to identify the market for a single new product. Analyses revealed that 89% of experts used effectuation more frequently than causation, while MBA students demonstrated a noticeably opposing preference, with 81% using causation more than effectuation.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Logical Frames in Entrepreneurial Decision Making : Differences between Experts and Novices
Author: Stuart Read

Ref. IMD 2006-14, December 2006.

Abstract:
Through a protocol analysis experiment comparing 27 expert entrepreneurs with 37 novices this study shows how expertise accumulated in the process of starting new ventures fundamentally changes the way entrepreneurs frame problems and make decisions. Results show that expert entrepreneurs employ non-predictive strategies within frames based on an effectual logic, whereas novices rely on more traditional predictive strategies based on causal frames. The generalization of these findings to the larger role of expertise in generating alternative frames in human decision making is also discussed.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Immortal Firms in Mortal Markets? An Entrepreneurial Perspective on the "Innovator's Dilemma"
Authors: Nicholas Dew, Saras D. Sarasvathy, Stuart Read and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2006-15, December 2006.

Abstract:
“The Innovator’s Dilemma” consists in the fact that by doing the right thing – i.e., listening to current customers -- leading firms often end up losing their markets to upstart newcomers. Therefore, understanding how entrepreneurs successfully create such upstart firms and new markets ought to have direct implications for theorizing about this dilemma. This paper examines implications of recent studies in entrepreneurial expertise, and outlines how an effectual logic of non-predictive control may be used to overcome the innovators’ dilemma in large corporations. The paper also identifies new questions for future research in the overlap between the origin and evolution of new markets and entrepreneurship.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Effectual Strategy and New Venture Performance : A Meta-Analysis
Authors: Stuart Read and Michael Song

Ref. IMD 2006-16, December 2006.

Abstract:
As academic interest in entrepreneurship grows, so does the requirement to ground empirical investigation with theory. This paper attempts to consolidate existing entrepreneurial study by applying the theoretical foundation of effectuation, a non-predictive approach to decision-making under uncertainty, to the issue of new venture performance. The authors find effectual constructs positively related to new venture performance suggesting effectuation in specific, and non-predictive strategies in general, may offer useful strategies for uncertain situations and insight into new venture performance. The authors close with a suggested agenda for advancing entrepreneurship research to a level commensurate with the best efforts in management.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Outlines of a Behavioral Theory of the Entrepreneurial Firm
Authors: Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read, Saras D. Sarasvathy and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2006-17, December 2006.

Abstract:
In A Behavioral Theory of the Firm (BTF), Cyert and March (1963) present a clutch of ideas for explaining the behavior of established firms within an environment of well-defined markets, stakeholder relationships, technologies, etc. In this paper, the authors outline a behavioral theory of the entrepreneurial firm that emphasizes transforming environments rather than acting within extant ones. In particular, the authors explicate three ideas that parallel key concepts in BTF: (1) accumulating stakeholder commitments under goal ambiguity (in line with a political conception of goals), (2) achieving control (as opposed to managing expectations) through non-predictive strategies; and, (3) predominately exaptive (rather than adaptive) orientation.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Prediction and Control under Uncertainty : The Outcomes of New Venture Investors
Authors: Robert Wiltbank, Stuart Read, Nicholas Dew and Saras D. Sarasvathy

Ref. IMD 2006-18, December 2006.

Abstract:
Venture investing is an important part of entrepreneurship not only because financial resources are important to new ventures, but also because early investors help shape the managerial and strategic destiny of new firms. This study makes a pioneering attempt to examine angel investor decision making from that perspective. Across the investing spectrum, angel investors represent the endpoint closest to uncertainty; placing funds in ventures that are very young, with fewer employees, revenues, and customers than any of their investing peers’ opportunities. The aim of this paper is to understand how this group approaches decision-making in such uncertain situations, and how that may influence the outcomes of their venture investments. The authors specifically evaluate the use of non-predictive control strategies by angel investors in a sample of more than 120 angel investors with over 1,000 new venture investments, and find the use of control strategies related to a reduction in new venture failures without reducing success rates. In addition to the theoretical contribution associated with developing and testing effectuation theory, this study represents the first quantitative performance study of angel investors of which we are aware. The implications of this study for managers and investors more broadly include important considerations of the boundary conditions for predictive strategy, as well as offering initial support for strategy based on control in highly uncertain situations.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

The More We Get Together : Coordinating Network Externality Product Introduction in the RFID Industry
Authors: Nicholas Dew and Stuart Read

Ref. IMD 2006-19, December 2006.

Abstract:
How organizations attempt to coordinate with one another in markets increasingly marked by network externalities is an emerging topic of interest for researchers working in the traditions of innovation studies and new product development. New network externality products often face complex “chicken-and-egg” coordination problems, since the user base and complementary goods that add to product value are not yet established. In this paper the authors highlight three mechanisms of spontaneous coordination among large numbers of organizations: focal points, leadership and common knowledge. The authors catalogue these three mechanisms at work using data from the RFID (Radio Frequency IDentification) industry.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

On the Entrepreneurial Genesis of New Markets: Effectual Transformations versus Causal Search and Selection
Authors: Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read, Saras D. Sarasvathy and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2006-20, December 2006.

Abstract:
Cumulated results from studies of industry evolution suggest the necessity to develop new micro-foundations concerning the creation of new markets. True to the traditions of evolutionary economics in directly incorporating empirical evidence from psychology and cognitive science, the authors present in-depth protocol analyses of how expert entrepreneurs, as opposed to novice managers, conceptualize the creation of new markets. Results challenge received wisdom based on search and selection processes, and move beyond combinatorial ideas to develop instead a “transformational” view of market genesis at the micro level that coheres better with existent findings at the macro level.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Research Project Effectiveness of Strategic Early Awareness Activities : Success Factors and Barriers
Authors: Alexander Nick and Ulrich Steger
Ref. IMD 2006-21, December 2006.

Abstract:
As the business environment becomes ever more fragmented and volatile, the need for management to generate and use consolidated knowledge about future developments and societal changes increases. Strategic early awareness is about the systematic investigation into alternative futures. The aim is to sensitize management towards future opportunities and threats that derive from a changing business environment. This empirical study explores strategic early awareness activities within ten multinational companies. It reveals success factors and provides recommendations on how to overcome current stumbling blocks. The main focus has been placed on activities within R&D, planning and risk management.
Full text (PDF, 224KB)
Inside the Mind of Stekeholders - Are they Driving Corporate Sustainability?
Authors: Oliver Salzmann, Ulrich Steger, Aileen Ionescu-Somers and Fabian Baptist

Ref. IMD 2006-22, December 2006.

Abstract:
This paper presents the key findings of an IMD study on stakeholders and their perceptions of (and approaches to) corporate sustainability. The study is based on 372 questionnaires and 280 interviews and takes a contingency approach across nine different stakeholder groups (e.g. financial institutions, NGOs, corporate customers and suppliers) and five European regions. The authors identify concepts related to corporate sustainability that are applicable across a variety of stakeholders. They determine meaningful clusters of stakeholders – based on the importance they attach to corporate sustainability and their level of satisfaction with it – and compare them across key concepts.
Full text (PDF, 544KB)

Corporate License to Operate (LTO) - Review of the Literature and Research Options
Authors: Oliver Salzmann, Aileen Ionescu-Somers and Ulrich Steger

Ref. IMD 2006-23, December 2006.

Abstract:
In preparation for a major empirical study on stakeholders and their approach to corporate sustainability, the authors review existing theoretical frameworks such as legitimacy theory and corporate social performance, key concepts such as the corporate license to operate and corporate sustainability management. In addition, they examine existing empirical studies in relevant areas, define primary research gaps and make suggestions for further research.
Full text (PDF, 104KB)

Working paper hard copies are available from IMD’s Information Center or from the IMD R&D archives. For Working Papers not available in full text, please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.


Full text is available for certain Working Papers in PDF format. Please click on the title column of any Working Paper to expand information.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.

Title Description
From a Hierarchy to a Heterarchy of Strategies : Adapting to a Changing Context
Authors: Bala Chakravarthy and James Henderson

Ref. IMD 2007-01, February 2007.

Abstract:
The purpose of this paper is to question the continued usefulness of the hierarchy of strategies framework and to propose a new approach. The hierarchy of strategies was a useful framework when it was first proposed, but since then a changed business context has made this framework obsolete. What is needed instead is a framework around a heterarchy of strategies. The locus of decision making is no longer hierarchical and corporate, business and functional strategies are far more interdependent and interlinked than they have been in the past. The paper provides a framework for managers whether from corporate, business divisions or functions to help with the continuous renewal of their firm.
Full text (PDF, 88KB)

The Role of Corporate Venture Capital Funds in Financing Biotechnology and Healthcare: Differing Approaches and Performance Consequences
Author: James Henderson

Ref. IMD 2007-02, February 2007.

Abstract:
Corporate venture capital (CVC) is an alternative financing mechanism to traditional venture capital for promising start-ups. Yet, these programs have been operated in very different ways with some focusing on “reserving the right to play” versus others focusing on “leveraging or upgrading the core.” The paper explores the role of these different CVC models and assesses the performance consequences for the start ups. Existing research has found that CVC programs that focused on ventures related to their base businesses were likely to have more initial public offerings and higher valuations than independent venture capitalists. Furthermore, researchers have found that this effect may be due to corporate endorsement and/or the relationships actually developed between the business unit and the entrepreneurial venture. This paper confirms these findings for the biotechnology context.
Full text (PDF, 192KB)

Cooperative Context, Learning and Negotiations in Supply Chain hold up Situations - Evidence from an Industy Simulation
Authors: Karel Cool and James Henderson

Ref. IMD 2007-03, February 2007.

Abstract:
This paper examines the link between the cooperative mechanisms to prevent supply chain hold-up and learning in negotiations. The analysis comes from data generated from an experiment based on the French Champagne industry. Results show that dyads where both parties have prior negotiation experience could best align context, intent, and negotiation approach with higher individual and joint outcomes. While dyads with asymmetric negotiation experience achieved more win-win outcomes than inexperienced dyads, their results still tended to be driven by the less experienced party. These results suggest that prior negotiation experience rather than cooperative context matters more for negotiation outcomes.
Full text (PDF, 240KB)

Integrating Compliance-based and Commitment-based Approaches in Corporate Sustainability Management
Authors: Catherine A. Ramus and Karin Oppegaard

Ref. IMD 2007-04, March 2007.

Abstract:
Businesses organizations take diverse approaches to managing environmental issues. Scholars have called for an integrative, unifying theory to study the multitidue of paths organizations take toward environmental sustainability. Our purpose in this paper is to present two such models, leveraging the ideas of commitment versus compliance. The models are organized around the principle that commitment- and compliance-based approaches are not necessarily mutually exclusive, but rather, when used together, can improve the effectiveness of environmental management. The first model brings together dispersed corporate sustainability, business management, and employee motivation literatures to argue for a process-based view of sustainability. In this model we describe a set of organizational mechanisms that exist on continuums at different organizational levels. The second model is used to explain the dynamic interactions that can occur over time between these different mechanisms and organizational levels. We conclude by arguing that commitment- and compliance-based approaches, when interacting dynamically in this way, can initiate complex and effective processes to move organizations toward environmental sustainability.
Full text (PDF, 152KB)

Corporate Sustainability - Food and Beverage
Authors: Clarissa Lins, Hiroshi C. Ouchi, Ulrich Steger, Oliver Salzmann and Aileen Ionescu-Somers

Ref. IMD 2007-05, April 2007.

Abstract:
This working paper is the result of research undertaken by the Brazilian Foundation for Sustainable Development (FBDS), with the assistance of technical and methodological support from the Forum for Corporate Sustainability Management (CSM) of IMD - International Institute for Management Development in Lausanne, Switzerland. CSM performed a similar study in Europe, the USA and Asia in the two-year period 2002-2003 in partnership with WWF, the global conservation organization. This study also had research support from COPPEAD Institute of Administration of the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ) and was sponsored by the following companies: Klabin, Tetra Pak and Banco Real ABN AMRO. The study used interviews, questionnaires and sectoral public and corporate information in order to assess the business case for corporate sustainability in three Brazilian business sectors, namely: pulp and paper, food and beverage, and electrical utilities. This working paper concerns the food & beverage (F&B) industry. The F&B industrial sector was chosen for this study because of its major relevance to the Brazilian economy and its exposure to both environmental issues – given its interference in and dependence on natural resources – and social issues, considering its share of responsibility in social impacts related to food such as malnutrition, obesity and responsible consumption. Between August and December 2005, we interviewed 22 top executives from five companies – AmBev, Coca-Cola Brasil, Nestlé Brasil, Perdigão and Sadia – and three representatives of stakeholder groups with strong vested interests in the sector (from a retail company and an NGO), as illustrated in graph 1. In addition, 30 professionals from top and middle management of the companies in the sector answered questionnaires.
Full text (PDF, 624KB)

How Growth Companies Distribute Value
Authors: Paul Strebel and Hongze Abraham Lu

Ref. IMD 2007-06, May 2007.

Abstract:
A majority of executives would give up economic value in exchange for current earnings. In contrast, founder CEO firms regularly sacrifice short term earnings for long term value. In this study, we compared the value distribution policies of founder CEO growth companies in a variety of global industries with growth laggards. Growth leaders systematically distribute more value to other stakeholders who are critical for their growth, despite the short term earnings impact. When they grow to dominate markets, they may try to boost earnings by extracting value from stakeholders who are not critical for their growth, but this often comes back to haunt them.

Practical Implications
To increase the long run value of the firm and avoid the trap of short term profit maximization, managers have to do four things that the successful growth leaders do:

  • Communicate the importance of the stakeholders who are critical for growth
  • Distribute value to the growth critical stakeholders, despite the short term earnings impact
  • Be wary of boosting earnings by extracting value from stakeholders who are not critical for growth
  • Ensure the net value distributed is positive for influential stakeholders

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Sponsoring Renewal
Authors: Bala Chakravarthy and Peter Lorange

Ref. IMD 2007-07, June 2007.

Abstract:
Entrepreneur-managers are highly desired in the corporate world. But few are successful unless they have an executive sponsor. The context that he/she sets for the shaping and implementation of a renewal project is vital to its success. Renewal requires taking risks, and the sponsor must manage these risks through the interactions and iterations he has with the entrepreneur-manager in the planning process. The sponsor must also ensure that the renewal project is housed in the proper organizational home to give it the right balance of autonomy and connectivity with the rest of the firm. Finally, the sponsor must deploy a control system with proper incentives, one that enforces discipline in implementation without killing the entrepreneurial spirit that is needed for the renewal efforts to succeed.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Corporate Sustainability - Electric Utilities
Authors: Clarissa Lins, Hiroshi C. Ouchi, Ulrich Steger, Oliver Salzmann and Aileen Ionescu-Somers

Ref. IMD 2007-08, June 2007.

Abstract:
This article is the result of research undertaken by the Brazilian Foundation for Sustainable Development (FBDS), with the technical and methodological support of the Forum for Corporate Sustainability Management (CSM) of IMD - International Institute for Management Development in Lausanne, Switzerland, an institution that performed a similar study in Europe, the USA and Asia in the two-year period 2002-2003 in partnership with WWF, the global conservation organization. The study, which was also given research support from COPPEAD Institute of Administration of the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ) and sponsored by the companies Klabin, Tetra Pak and Banco Real ABN AMRO, used interviews, questionnaires and sectoral public and corporate information in order to assess the business case for corporate sustainability in three Brazilian business sectors, namely: pulp and paper, food and beverage, and electric utilities. The electric utilities (EU) sector was chosen as part of the study for the following reasons: (i) its major impact and dependence on the environment, especially in the case of power generation; (ii) its impact on social wellbeing, either in the communities affected by dams and overhead power lines or by providing the population with access to energy. Moreover, it is a very important economic sector for Brazil and very representative in the capital market, as chapter 1 shows. Between August 2005 and February 2006, we carried out structured interviews with 33 top executives from the following companies: AES Group (Eletropaulo and Tietê), CEMIG, CPFL Energia, Elektro and Neoenergia. Two other executives with an active role in the sector were also interviewed: One in the regulatory agency and the other on the boards of directors of companies in the sector, as shown in graph 1. In addition, senior and middle managers from the companies under study answered 50 questionnaires.
Full text (PDF, 632KB)

Logical Frames in Entrepreneurial Decision Making : Differences between Experts and Novices
Authors: Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read, Saras D. Sarasvathy and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2007-09, June 2007.

Abstract:
Through a protocol analysis experiment comparing 27 expert entrepreneurs with 37 novices, this study shows how expertise accumulated in the process of starting new ventures fundamentally changes the way entrepreneurs frame problems and make decisions. The results show that expert entrepreneurs employ non-predictive strategies within frames based on an effectual logic, whereas novices rely on the more traditional predictive strategies based on causal frames. The generalization of these findings to the larger role of expertise in generating alternative frames in decision making is also discussed.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Continuous Renewal
Authors: Bala Chakravarthy and Peter Lorange

Ref. IMD 2007-10, June 2007.

Abstract:
Renovation is about protecting and extending a firm’s existing market share. It is achieved through continuous improvements in operating performance. It also calls for new product introductions, new approaches to servicing the customer and new ways of segmenting the existing market. Innovation, on the other hand, is about entering new markets and serving them using competencies that are also new to the firm. It stakes out a new business domain for the firm to grow profitably in the future. Continuous renewal is about renovation, innovation and more.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Why Merger and Acquisition (M&A) Waves Reoccur - The Vicious Circle from Pressure to Failure
Authors: Ulrich Steger and Christopher Kummer

Ref. IMD 2007-11, July 2007.

Abstract:
Merger and acquisition (M&A) activity is close to breaking new records and it has gained significant momentum over time. This development contradicts the fact that most M&As are considered to be unsuccessful. The authors are not surprised, however, at how difficult it seems to be to succeed in M&A transactions. Most studies stop at examining the success or failure rate of M&As and one or two obscure success factors. The authors are interested in the following question: Why do M&As continue to take place, not only on a small scale but also periodically with great magnitude, particularly when M&As in the previous wave – and even the ones before that – may have failed. In this paper the authors explore why companies, their management and shareholders are prepared to try over and over again, an aspect that M&A research has not explored to date.
Full text (PDF, 120KB)

Sustainable Banking with the Poor: Evolution, Status Quo and Prospects
Authors: Ulrich Steger, Alexander Schwandt and Matthieu Perissé

Ref. IMD 2007-12, October 2007.

Abstract:
Microfinance, i.e. the provision of financial services to people who would normally not be able to access them, has evolved very fast in the past few years, from a niche market dominated by social-welfare-oriented actors to an attractive growth market. Along with its mutation, new issues have appeared that are currently being addressed by the market players – historical actors and new entrants alike. Growth management, financing and competition-related topics are the key factors of the general trend characterizing the market, namely the commercialization of microfinance. This tendency raises a topical question for the years to come, with regard to the possible distortion of microfinance’s historical mission of social improvement.
Full text (PDF, 648KB)

On the Entrepreneurial Genesis of New Markets: Effectual Transformations versus Causal Search and Selection
Authors: Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read, Saras D. Sarasvathy and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2007-13, November 2007.

Abstract:
The generation of new markets is an emerging area of interest among researchers working in the traditions of evolutionary economics. And true to those traditions, the current study incorporates empirical evidence from psychology and cognitive science to develop micro-foundations for evolutionary theories of new market generation. In this paper we present an in-depth analysis of how expert entrepreneurs, as opposed to novice managers, use effectual logic to conceptualize the creation of new markets. Our results challenge received wisdom based on search and selection processes and move beyond combinatorial ideas to develop instead a "transformational" view of market genesis.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Prediction and Control under Uncertainty: Outcomes in Angel Investing
Authors: Robert Wiltbank, Stuart Read, Nicholas Dew and Saras D. Sarasvathy

Ref. IMD 2007-14, November 2007.

Abstract:
Venture investing plays an important role in entrepreneurship not only because financial resources are important to new ventures, but also because early investors help shape the ventures’ managerial and strategic destiny. In this study of 136 angel investors who had made 1,038 new venture investments, we empirically investigate angel investors’ differential use of predictive versus non-predictive control strategies. We show how the use of these strategies affects the outcomes of angel investors. Results show that angels who emphasize prediction make significantly larger venture investments, while those who emphasize non-predictive control experience a reduction in investment failures without a reduction in their number of successes.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Immortal Firms in Mortal Markets? An Entrepreneurial Perspective on the "Innovator's Dilemma"
Authors: Nicholas Dew, Saras D. Sarasvathy, Stuart Read and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2007-15, November 2007.

Abtract:
"The Innovator’s Dilemma" consists in the fact that by doing the right thing – i.e., listening to current customers - leading firms often end up losing their markets to upstart newcomers. Therefore, understanding how entrepreneurs successfully create such upstart firms and new markets ought to have direct implications for theorizing about this dilemma. This paper examines implications of recent studies in entrepreneurial expertise, and outlines how an effectual logic of non-predictive control may be used to overcome the innovators’ dilemma in large corporations. The paper also identifies new questions for future research in the overlap between the origin and evolution of new markets and entrepreneurship.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Designing Organizations that Design Environments: Lessons from Entrepreneurial Expertise
Authors: Saras D. Sarasvathy, Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2007-16, November 2007.

Abstract:
Human artifacts lie on the interface between their inner environments and their outer environments. Organizations, therefore, are apt subjects to be studied through a science of the artificial. Furthermore, organizational design happens at two interfaces: first, at the interface between organizational founder/s and the firms they design, and second, between the firms and the environments in which they operate. We use recent developments in the study of entrepreneurial expertise to show why an effectual logic of design is necessary at the first interface, and what its consequences are for designing at the second. In particular, we use the exemplar case of Starbucks to codify three key characteristics of the design problem at the first interface – namely, Knightian uncertainty, goal ambiguity, and environmental isotropy. We then use an "alternate histories" method to trace four strategic options – namely, planning, adaptation, vision, and transformation - for designing at the second interface. In the final analysis, organizational design is important because effectuators using transformational approaches not only design organizations, but concurrently end up designing the environments we live in.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

One More Challenge on the Road to Information Driven Marketing
Author: Martin A. Koschat

Ref. IMD 2007-17, November 2007.

Abstract:
Few CEOs would argue with the contention that a firm’s ability to generate timely market and customer insights comprises a set of critical operational and strategic competencies. There are indeed striking examples of firms that have achieved exceptional success through the disciplined use of data, analysis and information. Such success has stirred interest among leaders of many other firms who, too, have formulated information-based marketing strategies. The successful implementation of such strategies often requires considerable resources and a cultural change in the organization to embrace fact-based decision making. Yet despite a willingness to spend on information and to commit to cultural change, CEOs, their management teams and the organizations they lead may find the transition to information-driven marketing difficult. Ironically it is often the amount of information rather than the lack thereof that stands in the way of generating actionable and profitable insight.
Full text (PDF, 64KB)

So Much Data, so Little Time: How Analytics Can Help
Authors: Martin A. Koschat, Dilip Patel, Xiaolin Teng and Samaradasa Weerahandi

Ref. IMD 2007-18, November 2007.

Abstract:
An analytic – the software implementation of a set of precise rules for acquiring or retrieving data, analyzing the data and presenting the analytical results in a standardized format – is an effective tool for quickly gaining insights into structured data sets that are large and dynamically generated. Around a suite of business analytics, we describe basic concepts of design and illustrate these by presenting specific implementations. We discuss changes to statistical practice that may result from the deployment of analytics, and we argue that the increasing popularity of analytics has implications for statistical research and education.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Store Inventory Can Affect Demand: Empirical Evidence from Magazine Retailing
Author: Martin A. Koschat

Ref. IMD 2007-19, November 2007.

Abstract:
In retailing, inventory analysis and inventory practice have traditionally been based on the assumption that underlying demand does not vary with inventory levels. A growing body of research supports the contention that the validity of this assumption has significant implications for optimal inventory policies. The concern for such inventory effects motivated a major US magazine publisher to conduct the market study documented in this article. It presents empirical evidence that demand can indeed vary with inventory, and it quantifies the magnitude of these inventory effects which are two fold. An inventory decrease for one brand can, first, result in a decrease of demand for the brand and, second, in an increase of demand for a competing brand. These observations support the expansion of the traditional Newsvendor Model to include inventory effects as well as the practice to make inventory decisions for retail categories rather than individual brands.
Full text (PDF, 353KB)

Marketing under Uncertainty: A Knock on the Door
Authors: Stuart Read, Nicholas Dew, Saras D. Sarasvathy, Michael Song and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2007-20, November 2007.

Abstract:
How does one approach marketing in the face of uncertainty, where the product, the market and the traditional details involved in market research are unknowable ex ante? We use protocol analysis to evaluate how 27 expert entrepreneurs approach such a problem, compared to 37 novice managers, with all 64 participants being asked to think aloud as they make marketing decisions in exactly the same unpredictable situation. Our hypotheses are drawn from the literature in cognitive science on (a) expertise in general and (b) entrepreneurial expertise in particular. Results show significant differences in heuristics used by the two groups. While novices rely on predictive techniques, experts invert these. In particular, they use an effectual, or non-predictive logic to tackle uncertain market elements and construct novel markets. The 27 experts, for example, arrived at 28 different possible product-markets as opposed to only 12 envisioned by the 37 novices.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Effectual Strategy and New Venture Performance: A Meta-Analysis
Authors: Stuart Read and Michael Song

Ref. IMD 2007-21, November 2007.

Abstract:
Whether entrepreneurship is a process of sophisticated search or willful creation is among the key issues facing entrepreneurship scholars. We offer three contributions. First, we review major convergence areas of entrepreneurship literature against the backdrop of positioning and construction and show that the bulk of current work rests on the foundational assumption that opportunities are found and positioned within a given environment. Our second contribution is an empirical test of effectuation where we demonstrate a positive relationship between a creation-oriented approach and venture performance. Our third contribution is an agenda to gain balance between construction and positioning in entrepreneurship research.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Logical Frames in Entrepreneurial Decision Making: Differences between Experts and Novices
Authors: Nicholas Dew, Stuart Read, Saras D. Sarasvathy and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2007-22, November 2007.

Abstract:
Through a protocol analysis experiment comparing 27 expert entrepreneurs with 37 novices, this study shows how expertise accumulated in the process of starting new ventures fundamentally changes the way entrepreneurs frame problems and make decisions. The results show that expert entrepreneurs employ non-predictive strategies within frames based on an effectual logic, whereas novices rely on the more traditional predictive strategies based on causal frames. The generalization of these findings to the larger role of expertise in generating alternative frames in decision-making is also discussed.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Affordable Loss: Behavioral Economic Aspects of the Plunge Decision
Authors: Nicholas Dew, Saras D. Sarasvathy, Stuart Read and Robert Wiltbank

Ref. IMD 2007-23, November 2007.

Abstract:
Affordable loss involves decision makers estimating what they might be able to put at risk and examining what they are willing to lose in order to follow a particular course of action. This paper analyses how potential entrepreneurs may use the affordable loss heuristic in making the “plunge decision” to start a new venture. We show that affordable loss may be integrated with several frequently used approaches to making the plunge decision. We then explain the behavioral aspects of affordable loss in detail, focusing on how individuals decide what they can afford to lose, and how they decide what they are willing to lose in order to take the plunge into entrepreneurship. The paper also discusses the implications of affordable loss for the economics of entrepreneurship.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Framing Uncertainty: The Temporal Effects of Frames on the Use of Effectuation
Authors: Willem Smit and Stuart Read

Ref. IMD 2007-24, November 2007.

Abstract:
Roughly 7 of 10 executives in firms around the world use scenario and contingency planning to explore and prepare for alternative possible futures (Bain & Company Management Tools 2007 survey). Planning strategic response to foreseeable change in the environment is powerful when the situation is relatively predictable. But what if it does not? What if a mature environment shifts such that outcomes are sufficiently unrelated to historical patterns, making prediction irrelevant in usefully informing managerial decision-making? It is within this unruly but increasingly prevalent context that we place our work. And the heart of our effort revolves around the seemingly innocent question of what helps or hinders managerial shift in decision-making strategy to match the environment when the situation changes from predictable to uncertain. We build the foundation of our work on three pillars. We draw on Knight (1921) to articulate the uncertain condition. We build on Staw, Sandelands, & Dutton’s (1981) concept of framing to understand the perhaps biased lens through which a manager sees the environment. And we introduce Sarasvathy (2001) to offer an approach to strategic decision-making which does not rely on prediction. Combining these three bodies of work, we are led to the normative expectation that managers should perfectly match strategy to environment, and more specifically that when presented with uncertainty managers should utilize strategies such as effectuation which do not demand predictive inputs to function. But we are also warned of deep cognitive human biases, specifically the impact of framing on an individual’s objectivity regarding the environment, which constrains their ability to do what normatively should be done. The central contribution of our effort is the advancement of theory integrated with empirics which build our understanding of managerial decision-making when confronted with environmental uncertainty. In specific, the effort adds to thinking in the field by i) reviewing relevant literature on framing and strategy execution response, ii) developing relevant hypotheses based on our synthesis of the literature, iii) describing an interactive Internet-based simulation we created specifically for our investigation, iv) presenting the differences in how our unique sample of 202 corporate managers made decisions over time when faced with a predictable or uncertain situation, and v) articulating the implications of our findings, both for theory and for practice. Our findings suggest that while the corporate managerial response to uncertainty is to try harder to use prediction (in direct contradiction with normative expectations), framing can help accelerate the shift in response to uncertainty from prediction to an approach which does not depend on historical information. We close with a focus on this encouraging finding, offering theoretical implications that point to potentially useful research in the field, and practical implications that may help us enhance the way we prepare managers for the uncertainty they are likely to face in today’s unpredictable business context.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Working paper hard copies are available from IMD’s Information Center or from the IMD R&D archives. For Working Papers not available in full text, please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.

Full text is available for certain Working Papers in PDF format. Please click on the title column of any Working Paper to expand information.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.

Title Description
Corporate Sustainability in ASEAN – A look at how managers in Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand respond to it
Authors: Julie Guth and Ulrich Steger

Ref. IMD 2008-01, January 2008.

Abstract:
The 1992 Rio Declaration on Environment and Development stresses the importance of the business community in achieving the goals of sustainable development strategies. The purpose of this paper is to review the empirical evidence of corporate sustainability in the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). This paper examines industry’s response to the call for corporate sustainability in three of the wealthier ASEAN member nations: Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand. It focuses on the integration of the economic and environmental dimension of corporate sustainability. The research combines quantitative and qualitative research methods (211 questionnaires and 35 semi-structured interviews). It identifies the importance of corporate sustainability in business practice, looks at managers’ attitudes to environmental requirements as well as their perception of environmental pressure groups, and analyses drivers of and barriers to the implementation of corporate sustainability. The importance of corporate sustainability varies significantly in Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand. The data confirms a positive interdependence between economic and ecological performance. Furthermore, managers and companies behave rationally towards their political, business and social environment: Economic considerations are for example one of the most important levers for the implementation of environmental measures; environmental requirements of international customers and capital providers exert the strongest environmental pressure.
Full text (PDF, 208KB)

A Triangulation Trilogy
Author: Karsten Jonsen

Ref. IMD 2008-02, January 2008.

Abstract:
This paper describes how complementary triangulation methods can be used for verification and exploration of concepts and themes in qualitative studies. It argues that naturalistic inquiries, such as grounded theory and thematic analysis, can use mixed methods and multiple sources and coders in order to offset bias and to validate and explore conceptualization and categorization. Based on a managerial case-study, it demonstrates how a mix of existing techniques was applied to validate and sort findings.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

The Case of Diversity as a Potential Strategic Issue
Authors: Martha Maznevski, Karsten Jonsen and Susan Schneider

Ref. IMD 2008-03, January 2008.

Abstract:
With theory generation in mind, the authors followed an organization in order to analyze how it interpreted workforce diversity as a potential strategic issue. Based on this data, The authors coded observations, interviews and issue-relevant text/documents. They gave the codes analytical meaning and conceptualized the inputs into a model that presents the important perspectives on the issue under investigation. The authors confirmed the findings by applying triangulation techniques. The study generates a grounded theory explaining what goes on when diversity is discussed as a potential strategic issue in an organization, and it creates new insights into the understanding and interpretation of diversity as a strategic issue in a European context.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Unraveling the Diversity-Performance Link in Multicultural Teams: Meta-analysis of Studies in the Impact of Cultural Diversity in Teams
Authors: Guenter Stahl, Martha Maznevski, Andreas Voigt and Karsten Jonsen

Ref. IMD 2008-04, January 2008.

Abstract:
The aim of this study is to synthesize our current knowledge about the effect of cultural diversity on teams, and to outline possible avenues for future research. Previous research on this topic is equivocal, and suggests that cultural diversity’s effect on teams is mediated by specific team processes, and moderated by contextual variables. To reconcile conflicting perspectives and past results, the authors hypothesize that cultural diversity affects teams through process losses and gains associated with increased divergence and decreased convergence. They also propose effects of specific moderators in the discrete context. The authors then test the hypotheses with a meta-analysis of 108 empirical studies on processes and performance in 10632 teams. Results show that cultural diversity leads to process losses through task conflict and decreased social integration, but to process gains through increased creativity and satisfaction. Moderator analyses reveal that the effects of cultural diversity vary depending on contextual influences, such as task complexity, team size, team tenure and team dispersion, as well as on research design and sample characteristics. The authors propose an agenda for future research and identify implications for managers.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Does Culture Matter? Cross-Cultural Perceptions of Women and Men Leaders
Authors: Jeanine Prime, Karsten Jonsen, Nancy Carter and Martha Maznevski

Ref. IMD 2008-05, January 2008.

Abstract:
The authors examined perceptions of managers from four Western European cultural groups about women’s and men’s leadership. Participants from every cultural group perceived reliable gender-based differences in leadership effectiveness. More often than not, findings showed that participants’ gender – not their cultural beliefs – influenced these stereotypic perceptions. Unexpectedly, gender stereotypes of leaders were least prevalent among Latin respondents compared to those from more egalitarian cultures. In the Nordic and Anglo groups, male participants’ stereotypes disparaged women’s performance at highly valued leadership competencies. The implications for women’s leadership advancement in these different cultural contexts are discussed.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Why Look Back when Trouble is Ahead? How Environmental Frames Delay or Accelerate Strategy Adaptation to Uncertainty
Authors: Willem Smit and Stuart Read

Ref. IMD 2008-06, January 2008.

Abstract:
Many executives make use of prediction techniques to strategize for the future. But what if the environment shifts from being reasonably predictable to uncertain? And their company ends up in a situation where the past offers no predictive input to the future? Using an Internet-based simulation, we investigate whether managers shift from predictive decision-making in a stable environment to strategies which do not rely on historical information when faced with uncertainty. This experiment with 147 corporate managers shows that while managers do exactly the opposite of what theory suggests they should, that framing uncertainty as an opportunity can accelerate transition to a non-predictive decision-making approach under uncertainty while threat framing retards it.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Corporate Sustainability in the Brazilian Banking Sector
Authors: Clarissa Lins, Danniel Wajnberg, Ulrich Steger and Aileen Ionescu-Somers

Ref. IMD 2008-07, January 2008.

Abstract:
This paper is the result of research undertaken between December 2006 and August 2007 by the Brazilian Foundation for Sustainable Development (FBDS), with the technical and methodological support of the Forum for Corporate Sustainability Management (CSM) of IMD - International Institute for Management Development, an institution that performed a similar study in Europe, the USA and Asia in the two-year period 2002/2003 in partnership with WWF, the global conservation organization. The study, which was also given research support from COPPEAD Administration Institute of the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ) and sponsored by the Itaú, Itaú BBA and Bradesco banks, used interviews, questionnaires and sectoral public and corporate information in order to assess the business case for corporate sustainability in the banking sector in Brazil.
Full text (PDF, 2.64MB)

Working paper hard copies are available from IMD’s Information Center or from the IMD R&D archives. For Working Papers not available in full text, please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.

Full text is available for certain Working Papers in PDF format. Please click on the title column of any Working Paper to expand information.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.

Title Description
Sovereign Wealth Funds : Investment Choices and Implications around the World
Author: Nuno Fernandes

Ref. IMD 2009-01, February 2009.

Abstract:
This study focuses on a major global issue: the rise of sovereign wealth funds (SWFs). Using the largest data set of their holdings to date, we document a large SWF premium of more than 15% of firm value. Using data from 2002 through 2007 that includes SWF holdings in 8,000 firms in 58 countries, we find that firms with higher ownership by SWFs have higher firm valuations and better operating performance. Additionally, they tend not to invest heavily in firms in high-tech industries or those operating in areas involving intensive research and development.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Working paper hard copies are available from IMD’s Information Center or from the IMD R&D archives. For Working Papers not available in full text, please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.

Full text is available for certain Working Papers in PDF format. Please click on the title column of any Working Paper to expand information.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.

Title Description
In Touch Boards: Reaching Out to
the Value Critical Stakeholders

 

Author: Paul Strebel

Ref. IMD 2010-02, December 2010

Abstract:
The improvements in corporate governance made so far after each crisis have failed to address a fundamental weakness: boards are out of touch often with those who can make or break a company. To support value creation and prevent a future disaster, boards have to go beyond the analysts, consultants, government officials, and get in touch with the company’s shareholders and critical stakeholders, those that matter for creating long term value, sensing the related risk, and are relevant during the make or break periods in the life of the company. This paper introduces the concept of value critical stakeholders and describes how boards can be in touch with them. Boards need an outreach program, an explicit program of reaching out beyond the boardroom, comprising the following elements: identify which stakeholders are critical for value creation, adapt the composition of the board to enable reaching out to the value critical stakeholders, develop communication channels with them, tune into what they are saying and draw on them to promote the creation of long term value.

Full text not available (please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number of the working paper)

Working paper hard copies are available from IMD’s Information Center or from the IMD R&D archives. For Working Papers not available in full text, please contact our research department mentioning the title and reference number.
Note that IMD Working Papers need to be quoted - referenced - if used.



Your next step

Contact us



© 2012 IMD International. All Rights Reserved.